Appeal: House search in federal court
The Neuchâtel Public Prosecutor's Office is appealing to the Federal Supreme Court regarding the search of a journalist's home. The Cantonal Court had ruled that the search ordered by the Public Prosecutor's Office was illegal. An appeal is being filed against that ruling.
By order of the public prosecutor's office, police officers searched the home of journalist Ludovic Rocchi in mid-August and confiscated electronic data (Werbewoche.ch reported). Rocchi had uncovered a plagiarism affair at the University of Neuchâtel for Le Matin. The accused professor was provisionally suspended after an administrative investigation revealed partial plagiarism. However, the professor filed a lawsuit against the journalist for defamation, libel and violation of official secrecy. This complaint ultimately led to a house search.
House search illegal according to cantonal court
There was a huge outcry throughout Switzerland: the newspaper Le Matin, media unions and media experts denounced the action as a violation of press freedom. In mid-September, the cantonal court ruled that the house search was illegal. The confiscated material had to be returned immediately. The public prosecutor's office is not satisfied with this. Because the case law on the boundary between interests is not very extensive, the issue is to be clarified by the highest court.
Balancing interests and freedom of the press
The public prosecutor's office stated in the press release on Monday that it does not deny the importance of protecting the freedom of the press. In cases involving a journalist, a balance must always be struck between freedom of the press and other principles. In this case, it was the principle that allowed the authorities to make decisions calmly and without external pressure. In the opinion of the public prosecutor's office, the university lecturer does not represent a sufficient point of contention for the public to cover the affair in the press before the authorities have decided on the case.
Chief public prosecutor defends his authority
In the one-and-a-half page press release, Chief Public Prosecutor Pierre Aubert also defended himself against the insinuations made by certain media outlets that the house search was a retaliatory measure against a journalist who was too inquisitive. Nor was it a question of protecting a well-known person. The criminal authorities would carry out their work according to the seriousness of the alleged offenses and not according to the identity or status of the persons concerned.
Imprint confident
In a press release issued on Monday evening, the journalists' association Impressum expressed confidence that the public interest in media freedom would be given greater weight by the Federal Supreme Court. The public prosecutor's office is playing down the protection of media professionals' sources, although this is a fundamental prerequisite for the functioning of the media in the service of democracy. In addition, the authorities - in this case the public prosecutor in his statement - should under no circumstances presume to judge what the media should report on. The media themselves decide what reporting is in the public interest. (SDA/hae)
