Press Council: Controversial approval for image publication

Can a newspaper rely on the assurance of the director of a workshop for people with disabilities that those present during a photo shoot consented to the publication of the photos? The Press Council does not consider this sufficient in every case.

He therefore recommends either insisting on written consent or consulting directly with those photographed. In March 2013, the Wochenblatt für das Birseck und Dorneck published a report on a workshop for the disabled and showed a photo of a man doing woodwork. The fact that non-disabled unemployed people also work in the workshop was not at all apparent from the caption and only with difficulty from the article. According to a press release, the man pictured complained to the Press Council about the violation of his personality and human dignity. The publication of the picture had not been agreed upon in such a way. He is unemployed, but not disabled - the picture reduces his chances on the job market. The editor-in-chief of the "Wochenblatt" claimed that he had clarified with the head of the facility before the photo session that all those present would be willing to be photographed for publication. The Press Council partially upheld the complaint. Because the complainant can be perceived as a disabled person by part of the readership, the personality is violated. The mere mention or hint of a disability, however, does not degrade the human dignity of the person concerned.
 

More articles on the topic