Experimental field
Total Audience 1.2: Combined usage figures for printed and digitally published press content are available for the third time. The largest titles have been able to massively expand their reach in some cases. However, the question arises as to whether this study really helps the market.
Like its predecessor studies, Total Audience 1.2 provides gross and net reach figures for combinations of paper and digital usage. It also shows the users of both offerings as well as the exclusive users of one or the other offering. In contrast to MA Strategy, it provides results at currency level as readers per issue (LpA) or unique users per day (UUpD), week (UUpW) or month (UUpM). Holders of a corresponding license can calculate individual socio-demographic profiles. Media plans, on the other hand, cannot be calculated. However, this would hardly make sense due to the very incomplete selection of titles.
The (surveyed) reach of the printed press titles and the structural data come from MACH Basic 2012-2 and therefore represent the average for the period from April 2011 to March 2012. The information on the use of digital offerings comes from NET-Metrix 2012-2, which reflects usage in the second quarter of 2012, i.e. after the print survey was completed. Every two years, some of the respondents also take part in an online follow-up survey following the MACH Basic Interview. It is designed so that the results can be directly linked to the NET-Metrix-Audit web statistics data, which in turn forms the basis for the NET-Metrix profile survey.
The current study includes data from daily newspapers, the two Sunday titles SonntagsBlick and NZZ am Sonntag as well as Beobachter, Bilanz, Handelszeitung and PCtipp. In the following observations, we therefore limit ourselves to the daily press market, which is at least halfway complete, and use the correct comparative value of unique users per day (UUpD) for online usage.
Big gets bigger

The chart "Total use of daily press offerings" shows the number of exclusive print and web users as well as double users for all reported titles. The chart does not include 20 Minuten, which only reports its figures nationally. A presentation in this chart would therefore give the wrong impression. With a total of 2.248 million net contacts, 20 Minuten reaches more than twice as many users nationally as Blick and Blick am Abend, both of which have just under one million net contacts in just one language version. Their print reach increases by more than half due to the inclusion of digital users. This is by far the highest increase of all the titles reported (see chart "Reach growth of daily press through digital offerings").

The Neue Zürcher Zeitung also achieved a high additional reach thanks to its digital offerings, with growth of around 40 percent. With total usage by around 400,000 people, it is even just ahead of the combined editions of the Berner Zeitung and Bund. In contrast, the position of all other titles has not changed due to the inclusion of digital usage. It is also clear that only the four top-ranked titles can really improve their reach significantly by including digital usage. At just under 14%, the increase for 20 Minuten national is comparatively low. However, at around 9 percent, the proportion of dual print/digital users is highest for this title (see chart "Usage distribution of daily press offerings"). This is followed by Blick and Tages-Anzeiger with around 8 percent each, Blick am Abend and Tribune de Genève with around 7 percent each and Basler Zeitung with a good 6 percent. The lowest proportion of double users is Le Temps with just 2 percent. It is difficult to say whether and to what extent this is related to the paywall that was introduced some time ago.

No offensive marketing
In the knowledge of the increase in reach through digital offerings, at least the major titles should offer a package that enables total digital usage on a particular day of the week, but this is only being approached tentatively and not offensively. At Blick, Managing Director Caroline Thoma went on record shortly before her departure: "The fact that there are still few to no integrated offers is due to the fact that the majority of agencies plan on a channel basis, there are no intermedia comparisons in terms of metrics and customers are often skeptical about online - because there is (still) no proof of advertising effectiveness." However, the Blick Group has been offering the service of customized packages for some time. And mini cross-media offers have been created for small customers. In addition, every customer can open a joint contract for print and mobile.
Marcel Tappeiner, publishing director of the Tages-Anzeiger, has a similar view. He points out that the requirements for the respective media genre are too specific for national campaigns. Combined offers, on the other hand, are negotiated individually - if they are requested at all. He sees the future of such combined offers primarily in the local market. In his view, the total audience is sufficient for a general view of the performance of a media brand. For concrete media planning and pricing, however, the key figures are not sufficient, especially for online.
At NZZ, the answer already shows that not only the agencies think in terms of channels. Both Remo Baumeler, Head of Advertising Market NZZ Network, and Stefan Bai, Head of Advertising Market NZZ, had to be consulted in order to answer the MTJ's questions. They also point out that print/digital packages are put together individually according to customer requirements.
The furthest along in terms of overall marketing is 20 Minuten, which merged its sales a year ago. But here, too, there are no all-inclusive combination packages - although the BrandyDay promotional offer and the combination of print with tablet and mobile placements are available on request.
Who wants Total Audience?
To summarize, it can be said that research has probably laid an appropriate foundation. But neither agencies nor publishers have drawn any conclusions from this. The agencies argue that print and online are two different media with completely different modes of action. An argument that cannot be dismissed out of hand. But this is the case with every type of total audience. One can therefore ask oneself whether this is the right approach at all. In this respect, the MA Total Audience provides important food for thought before the WEMF launches a comprehensive hub concept. After all, TV, radio, posters and cinema also have a different effect and function than print or online. The potential users of a hub study should definitely be included in the development. Otherwise, this model will end up like the QMS quality media study around 20 years ago, which was loudly demanded by all advertisers and media experts in the run-up to its publication, but disappeared without a trace after its publication. This must not happen with the hub concept.
Ueli Custer
