Federal Court: Schmidheiny loses dispute with SRG

Stephan Schmidheiny has lost his dispute with SRG SSR over a report on asbestos victims at Eternit factories in Italy. The Federal Supreme Court has upheld the UBI's decision.

At the beginning of the year, the Independent Complaints Authority for Radio and Television (UBI) came to the conclusion that the documentary broadcast by Ticino television in September 2011 was not objectionable. Entrepreneur Schmidheiny had argued that the program violated the requirement of objective reporting. The UBI countered that it was always clear to viewers of the 55-minute report that the program was examining the asbestos problem from the perspective of the victims. This had also been pointed out by the moderator.

Present point of view

As reported by the newspapers Tages-Anzeiger and Der Bund in their editions of Tuesday, the Federal Supreme Court has now confirmed the UBI's decision and dismissed Schmidheiny's appeal. The judges in Lausanne reminded that the information mandate does not go so far that the defense position of the person concerned would also have to be represented. However, their point of view must be sufficiently presented. As far as the then pending trial against Schmidheiny in Italy was concerned, the presumption of innocence had been respected. Last June, a Turin appeals court had sentenced Schmidheiny to 18 years in prison in the trial over the asbestos deaths of workers. Schmidheiny plans to appeal the verdict. (SDA)

Image: Keystone

More articles on the topic