Federal court rules in favor of Observer journalist
The public has a constitutional right to know which judges issued a particular ruling. According to the Federal Supreme Court, a journalist must be informed of the judges who issued a ruling.
The Federal Asylum Appeals Commission, which was merged into the Federal Administrative Court in 2007, had made a landmark decision in 2005: people from Eritrea who deserted before serving in the army are considered refugees because they face severe mistreatment if they return. A reporter for the Observer, in connection with an article on Swiss refugee policy in 2012, asked the Federal Administrative Court to send him the decision and to disclose the judges who would have been involved in it. The court's secretary general sent the ruling but refused to disclose the panel of judges.
Wrongly, as the Federal Court has now ruled on the journalist's appeal. In their decision, the judges in Lausanne refer to Article 30 of the Federal Constitution, which enshrines the principle of judicial publicity.
No secret justice
In concrete terms, this constitutional provision guarantees that a judgment - no matter how important or insignificant - can be taken note of by the public. In principle, this right extends to the entire judgment, including the facts of the case, the reasons, the dispositions and the judges involved.
According to the court, the principle of judicial publicity ensures the transparency of judicial proceedings and means a rejection of any form of secret justice. The principle is of central importance for the rule of law and democracy and also serves to create trust in the judiciary.
Restrictions possible
According to the Federal Supreme Court, if the persons involved in a decision could remain unknown, the control function associated with the principle of publicity would be impaired or even illusory. Moreover, judges would exercise a public office and would also have to face possible criticism.
However, according to the court, restrictions to the principle of publicity are possible if this is necessary to protect personal or public interests. In this respect, it was also permissible in the present case for the name of the complainant concerned to be made anonymous.
As far as the responsible judges were concerned, however, it was not evident why they should no longer stand by their judgment and why they should be protected in their trust in anonymity. (Judgment 1C_390/2012 of March 26, 2013, BGE publication) (SDA)
