Journalists must also pay for access to official documents
According to the Federal Administrative Court, media professionals may also be required to pay a fee to access official documents. The judges in St. Gallen dismissed the appeal filed by a journalist from the consumer magazine K-Tipp.
In 2010, the journalist had asked the Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE) for information regarding the testing of energy labels on electrical appliances as part of an investigation. After he was not satisfied with the answers provided by e-mail, he submitted a request to view the relevant documents. The SFOE informed him in advance that it would charge a fee of CHF 250 for his efforts. The journalist received a corresponding invoice after the inspection. He then challenged the fee order before the Federal Administrative Court.
The Federal Administrative Court has now rejected his appeal. The decision can still be appealed to the Federal Supreme Court. The K-Tipp employee had argued that the media play an important role in forming opinions in democratic societies. The fulfillment of this task is hindered by the state if it charges fees for providing information to media professionals. The judges in St. Gallen firstly pointed out that, according to the Public Access Act, every person has the right to inspect public documents that are not subject to secrecy. According to the law, an expense-based fee must be paid for this. There is no exemption for the media. The freedom of information and media freedom enshrined in the Federal Constitution would guarantee the right to receive and obtain information freely and to disseminate information unhindered. However, these fundamental rights would not provide any entitlement to a state service such as the free processing of requests for access.
Finally, according to the court, the amount of the fee of CHF 250, which was set on the basis of five hours of work, is not objectionable. According to the ruling, the SFOE had to check the document in question sentence by sentence in order to anonymize certain passages. Internet searches were also necessary. In addition, an internal exchange had to be carried out. (SDA)
