Like the Germans or like the French?
Private marketplaces are one possible solution for encouraging publishers to participate in RTA trading. Will there be an industry-wide solution for this in our market?
The online advertising business is changing fundamentally as the focus shifts from the masses to the individual user. The well-established routine business of media buying, characterized by fixed price lists around thousand-contact prices (CPM), is being replaced by auction processes. The keyword here is Real Time Bidding (RTB). This method was initially used by Google to determine the price of ad words, and there have long been a number of ad exchanges that work according to the same principle. This favors buyers, who can use anonymized profile data to buy advertising for precisely those consumers with whom their message is likely to have the greatest chance of success. Publishers are different. Because the focus is not on quality, but above all on price, they fear falling prices. That is why they do not open up their inventory to automated trading. Game over for so-called Real Time Advertising (RTA)?
No, because the revenue potential associated with RTA is so tempting that providers are now coming forward with solutions that address publishers' concerns. The keyword here is private exchange. Instead of trading inventory on the public marketplace, the Ad Exchanges, transactions are - metaphorically speaking - conducted in separate rooms in the adjoining luxury hotel. Nothing new, just implemented via software. With such exclusive marketplaces, publishers can control exactly how they sell their inventory. It is possible to control very precisely which buyers have access to which inventory and under which conditions. Trading still typically takes place according to RTB methods, which is why such preferential conditions are not granted exclusively to a single buyer, but rather to a small, hand-picked group (see "prioritized bidding" in the adjacent RTA glossary). This allows prices to be kept at the usual level and efficiency gains to be realized at the same time. In addition, buyers and sellers can be sure that the environment for their advertising is right and that ads of questionable origin do not suddenly appear on a premium site simply because they were bought at auction via an open ad exchange.
Providers of SSP solutions in particular have further developed their technologies in order to realize private marketplaces. These include companies such as AppNexus, Admeld (owned by Google), PubMatic and Rubicon Project. According to an overview by Forrester Research from early 2012, not all of them are equally advanced and offer different or differently mature features. Accordingly, there are different implementations on the market: The Weather Channel is the sixth-largest website in the USA with 15 million web clients every day. At this scale, a private exchange can also be implemented on its own in order to optimize the processing of purchase requests and gain insights for future tactics and strategy. The advanced technology of a private exchange is used instead of a conventional sales-side platform. In Europe, for example, the online media group Hi-Media, the European market leader for online advertising and electronic payment transactions on the internet, announced in September 2011 that it would be launching its own ad exchange together with AppNexus.
QuadrantOne is a joint venture between the US publishers Tribune Company, Gannett, Hearst and the New York Times and is therefore comparable to the Premium Publishers Network PPN, which was launched by Tamedia, NZZ and Ringier in March 2012. In contrast to PPN, where RTB trading is to be avoided for as long as possible, QuadrantOne has its own private exchange solution in the form of Q-Exchange. According to a white paper from Admeld, better results can be achieved with RTB than with other sales methods. Thanks to the joint approach, conflicts between the various channels can be reduced on the standardized platform.
La Place Media is a similar joint venture between French publishers that was launched in September 2012 and through which the websites of more than 80 media brands are marketed. As Managing Director Fabien Magalon explained at the time, the various partners had previously gained their own experience with RTB from various providers and came to the conclusion that they could only achieve the necessary market position with a strong alliance. The first goal was to achieve a relevant size in the market, which is currently dominated by Google's Ad Exchange and may also be dominated by Facebook in the future. Individual publishers would have no chance of being recognized alongside each other. In contrast, the combined size is now driving demand. Magalon sees a further advantage in the data that is collected jointly and used for all partners to improve reach quality.
A third plus point is the team of experts that the joint venture makes available to all partners for dealing with the new technology, for example to increase quality and avoid cannibalization. It is well known that people in France are used to centralized procedures, which is why it is not surprising that the minimum prices (floor price) on La Place Media are the same for all participants. The situation is quite different in Germany, where four independent players in the German digital economy launched an alliance for more quality in online advertising under the label 4Q ("for quality") at the end of October 2012. This promptly met with criticism, especially from those who had not been invited. Although not explicitly articulated as such, it became clear that the 4Q initiative does not have much to do with real-time bidding and sees quality as a continuation of the usual procedures. A large RTB coalition based on the French model is therefore not foreseeable in Germany.
At the beginning of November 2012, online marketer InteractiveMedia announced a premium publisher platform for its 60 sites in cooperation with AppNexus, which is set to commence full operations on January 1, 2013. At the same time, the Competence Center "Real Time Advertising in the Digital Media Market" was founded in cooperation with Goethe University Frankfurt am Main. The aim is to scientifically investigate and support the changes in the digital media market through real-time advertising approaches. And at the beginning of December, SpiegelQC, the Spiegel Group's marketing unit, announced the launch of "Premium Private Exchange", emphasizing that RTB is an important pillar of its own premium strategy.
Although individual players among media agencies and marketers in the Swiss advertising market have jumped on the RTB bandwagon, there are currently no concrete initiatives for a joint approach. However, there are increasing signs that the various companies are taking a closer look at the topic of RTA. The coming weeks and months will show whether RTA is to be established here according to the German model (everyone against everyone) or the French model (all together). This raises the question of whether the three small Swiss submarkets in the three national languages are large enough for their own solutions or whether cooperation with foreign partners in the respective language areas might make more sense. Conversely, going it alone with a nationally oriented private exchange solution based on the French model would offer attractive advantages: Automated trading could be set up throughout the country in such a way that the modalities are coordinated with all participants. This would provide publishers with an environment that allows them to enter RTA trading with attractive inventories. To facilitate this, a Swiss RTA solution can rely heavily on the development of know-how and its communication and application. Ultimately, this allows much better data to be obtained, which should be available to all participants.
Christoph J. Walther

RTA Glossary
The term Real Time Bidding is appearing more and more frequently - and it is not least the term "bidding" that is causing publishers to fear a price collapse. This is why the term RTA (Real Time Advertising) is now often used instead of RTB. Although it no longer appears in the name, the principle of determining prices for individual impressions via an auction process in real time still exists. But it does not have to be the main focus. RTA methods can also be used to process bookings at the established fixed prices. However, this is much more efficient than is the case with the previous, often largely manual procedures. Anyone familiarizing themselves with the world of Real Time Advertising will come across a number of English technical terms, which we will briefly describe here and deliberately refrain from attempting to translate.
Ad Networks: These companies connect advertisers with websites that want to distribute ads for a fee. Their main function is to aggregate the advertising space of numerous publishers and match it with the demand of advertisers, who can then buy this advertising space in a single place. Ad networks can use special technologies to create added value for both publishers and advertisers. They try to distinguish themselves with better methods for precise targeting, the quality of the publishers they represent and the quality of the advertisers and their campaigns. Unlike marketers (sales houses), ad networks often do not work exclusively.
Ad Exchange: Technology platforms that mediate supply and demand for digital advertising space. They stand above the ad networks, as these are among their customers. Their approach is technology-driven and geared towards online trading in real time. Auction processes (bidded buying) are used, which are geared towards individual ad impressions for a specific user. This distinguishes them from the conventional approach, as prices are negotiated based on specific inventory volumes.
Private Exchange: A private exchange is an exclusive marketplace through which premium publishers can sell their inventory with full control (see adjacent article).
Supply Side Platform (SSP): Technical solutions that enable publishers to offer digital advertising space for real-time trading. They promise efficient, automated and secure access to demand sources and provide insights into the various revenue streams and target groups. They are often referred to as sell-side platforms and are the counterpart to DSPs.
Demand Side Platform (DSP): Technical solutions for purchasing digital advertising in real time, whereby target groups can be defined, bids managed and performance measured. This can simplify and accelerate workflows.
Trading Desk: The entire organizational superstructure in agencies to buy and optimize target groups from ad networks, ad exchanges, individual SSPs or other correspondingly accessible sources using a DSP solution or their own comparable technology.
Data Management Platform, DMP: A technical solution with which data from various sources can be obtained and managed in connection with DSP or SSP so that purchases or offers can be improved.
Data Supplier: They collect data about online consumers (or their web browsers), compile it and sell it in anonymized form, often via data exchanges. Such data includes geographical or demographic characteristics, lifestyle, income and consumer behavior.
Data Exchange: An online trading platform comparable to ad exchanges, where anonymized data on online consumption can be bought and sold.
Targeted Advertising: Advertising messages are delivered individually on the basis of consumer data, with the aim of achieving the best possible match with the target group.
Online Contextual Advertising: Advertising is delivered on a website in accordance with its content.
Behavioral marketing (behavioral targeting): Target groups are selected using data on consumer behavior.
Retargeting: The design and delivery of advertising messages is based on the actions of consumers online. For example, if order forms are filled out on a website but not sent, the consumer is sent appropriately designed advertising messages on other websites to encourage them to complete the order.
Price Floor: Minimum prices set by publishers on private exchanges for specific parts of their inventory.
Prioritized Bidding: With this technique, publishers on private exchanges can grant certain buyers preferential conditions under certain conditions. In return for a certain price and/or volume, preferential conditions (so-called "first look") are granted for certain inventories. These special conditions are often granted not only to one buyer, but to a selected group. Additional trading features of a publisher on a private exchange (full transparency, narrower target group selections, etc.) are often only available to first-look customers. Prioritized bidding is also referred to as "guaranteed RTB" or "private ad slots".
Second Price Auction: An auction process in which the highest bidder only has to pay the price of the second-highest bid. This system is most frequently used in RTA trading.
Tagging a Page: The insertion of small program chunks into a website when it is delivered to the user in order to collect data about this visitor and use it later.
cjw
