Advertising impact: four success factors
What determines the success of an advertising campaign? According to a new study from the United Kingdom, four factors are key.
Firstly, you need the right mix of long-term and short-term measures. Secondly, it pays to address the entire market, not just individual segments. Thirdly, it pays to make advertising emotional. And fourthly, campaigns that rely on TV advertising are significantly more effective than other campaigns.
For several years now, the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA) and the British TV industry organization Thinkbox have been investigating what distinguishes successful from less successful advertising campaigns. In a new study, 996 campaigns from the IPA database have now been scrutinized. The campaigns were analyzed in terms of various impact parameters. For example, the number of "business effects" was examined, i.e. the question of how many areas (such as sales, revenue, market share, price elasticity) a campaign achieves strong positive effects. Another measure of success considered in the study is "Annualized ESOV efficiency". This efficiency indicator shows the percentage by which the market share grows per year if the share of voice is 10 percent higher than the market share.
So what are the findings of this study? An initial key finding is that companies should strive for the right mix of long-term brand building activities and short-term measures to increase sales. Short-term, activating advertising activities lead to an average of 0.7 positive "business effects". Brand-building measures have stronger effects; on average, they have an impact in 1.3 areas. However, a combination of activating and brand-oriented measures works best: on average, it leads to positive business effects in 1.5 areas. From an efficiency point of view, it is also advisable to combine brand-building and sales-promoting activities. Compared to the isolated use of brand-building measures, ESOV efficiency can be doubled (0.6 vs. 0.3). A second finding is that campaigns that address the entire market are more effective than those that only focus on existing or new customers. Advertising measures that are aimed solely at existing customers achieve positive business effects in 2.2 areas on average, while pure new customer campaigns achieve positive effects in 5.6 areas. Campaigns that target both existing and new customers generate an average of 6.7 positive business effects.
Clemens Koob
Key facts
- Campaigns should be short-term, sales-boosting and long-term oriented.
Combine branding activities.
- Compared to purely brand-building activities, this leads to more
positive business effects (1.5 vs. 1.3) and higher ESO efficiency
(0.6 vs. 0.3).
- Campaigns that appeal to the entire market generate more business.
effects (6.7) than campaigns only for existing (2.2) or new customers
(5,6).
- Emotions work better: 29% of the emotional, but only 16% of the
rational campaigns lead to strong revenue growth. Emotional
Campaigns are also more efficient (ESOV efficiency 0.8 vs. 0.3).
- Campaigns that use TV achieve 41% more positive business effects.
They are also significantly more efficient (ESOV efficiency 0.6 vs. 0.1).

