Advertising impact: TV commercials are not only effective on TV

Today, consumers watch TV on devices other than their televisions. But what is the actual impact of TV commercials on these various devices? A recent study led by Australia’s Murdoch University provides valuable insights.

The television in the living room is still an important media fixture - but it has lost its TV monopoly. Consumers today also use PCs, laptops, tablets and smartphones to watch TV. It is therefore interesting to see how TV commercials work on such alternative devices. With the help of experiments in which a total of around 1000 Australian consumers took part, the effect of TV commercials on televisions, PCs and cell phones has now been compared. As part of the experiments, the study participants - who were assigned to different groups - were shown around 30-minute TV programs including commercial breaks. Depending on the group to which they belonged, either a conventional TV set, a PC or a cell phone was used to watch TV. The impact of the TV commercials was then recorded in a survey. Four parameters were measured: Advertising recall and liking, attitudes towards the advertised brands and willingness to buy. The interesting result: TV commercials have a high impact - regardless of the device on which they are viewed. The study showed no statistically significant differences in impact between the devices.

Consumers in the TV group were able to recall 39% of the commercials without support. In the cell phone group, unaided advertising recall was also 39%. In the PC group, even slightly higher recall values were achieved at 46%, but the deviation is not statistically significant. TV commercials also achieved comparable likability ratings on all devices: on a 7-point scale with 7 as the best value, TV commercials on TV were given an average rating of 4.8. The spots received the same likability rating when viewed on a cell phone (4.8), while the likability ratings on a PC (4.7) were only slightly lower. A similar picture emerges with regard to consumer attitudes towards the advertised brands and willingness to buy. Consumers consistently showed a positive attitude towards the advertised brands, regardless of whether the TV advertising was viewed on a TV set, PC or cell phone (4.9 on a 7-point scale with a top score of 7 in each case). In the TV group, the willingness to buy the advertised products was 32%. In the cell phone group (28 %) and the PC group (27 %), the willingness to buy was slightly lower at first glance - however, the difference proved to be statistically insignificant. TV commercials are therefore not only effective on traditional televisions, but also on alternative end devices such as PCs or smartphones - and comparably well.

In everyday life, it is also often the case that consumers see the same commercial several times - possibly on different devices. From the perspective of advertising companies, it is of interest in this respect whether the combination and order of the devices on which a TV commercial is viewed affect the impact of the commercial. The study shows that this is not the case: in terms of advertising impact, it makes no significant difference whether a commercial is viewed first on a TV set and then again on a cell phone, first on a cell phone and then on a TV set, first on a PC and then again on a TV set or first on a cell phone and then again on a PC. All device combinations are similarly effective.

Clemens Koob

Unbenannt-10_7
 

More articles on the topic