Advertising ban: Caritas criticizes self-regulation
Credit companies should no longer be allowed to target customers with aggressive advertising. This is what the Economic Committee (WAK) of the National Council is proposing. The fact that the industry itself should define what is considered too aggressive is a source of irritation for Caritas.
The aim of the law is to prevent people from being tempted by enticing advertisements from companies to take out a loan that they cannot afford and that can drive them into a spiral of debt. The issue is largely undisputed, as the consultation process has shown. Differences exist on the question of how an effective law can be achieved. The proposed self-regulation, which the industry itself has worked on, has met with fierce criticism. A new convention is to regulate what type of advertising is considered non-aggressive - and is therefore exempt from the ban.
Controversial power of definition
Caritas is fundamentally disconcerted by the fact that the definition is left to the credit companies. It seems hardly credible that the "profiteers of this system" would significantly restrict their advertising, writes Caritas, especially as there are no specific rules on what constitutes unlawful, aggressive advertising. According to the convention, for example, advertising for consumer credit that particularly appeals to young adults under the age of 25 is prohibited, as is advertising in corresponding leisure facilities and gambling salons. Furthermore, companies may not advertise
"Express loans" or "instant loans" if they suggest that these are available without conditions. The ban also includes particularly aggressive advertising methods in public.
Controversial effect of self-regulation
The regulation also provides for the Swiss Fair Trading Commission (SLK) to be entrusted with the enforcement of the convention. The SLK can impose penalties of up to CHF 100,000 in the event of a breach. In addition, the Federal Council is to declare the convention generally binding. This system is in line with "tried and tested Swiss tradition", writes the Association of Swiss Credit Banks and Financial Institutions (VSKF) - as it
is practiced in tobacco and alcohol advertising, for example. The comparison with tobacco advertising is misleading, argues Caritas: according to a report by the Federal Office of Public Health, such agreements are largely ineffective. In the eyes of the French-speaking Swiss consumer protection association FRC, only clear legal regulations provide consumers with sufficient protection against over-indebtedness. The credit industry, for its part, considers self-regulation to be sufficient.
Obligation to report is rejected
The law also tightens up creditworthiness checks. In future, consumers who deliberately provide false information about their creditworthiness will be reported to the Information Office for Consumer Credit (IKO). Credit institutions and consumer organizations are opposed to this. The unanimous opinion is that this would force such institutions into the role of policeman and judge. The Swiss Bankers Association (SwissBanking) argues that such a reporting obligation could create problems with data protection.
The reporting obligation is disproportionate, criticizes SwissBanking. Moreover, it is not the bank's responsibility to decide whether borrowers have intentionally or negligently provided false information. The law was initiated by the Vaud SP National Councillor Josiane Aubert with a parliamentary initiative. The current preliminary draft was drawn up in the WAK and will now go to the National Council. The consultation ends on Monday. (SDA)
Image: Keystone
