We're loving it

When does a brand become a cult brand? What values must it convey in order to forge an emotional connection? Answers to these questions can be found in the book *The Cultural Branding Model*. A preview.

Brand management has changed in many ways since the 1940s. Rosser Reves« Unique Selling Proposition (USP) in the 1940s was based primarily on communicating functional benefits (e.g., M&Ms: »Melts in your mouth, not in your hand«) and was considered a groundbreaking branding strategy. The renowned professor David Aaker criticized this functional approach in various publications. In the 1970s, Aaker proposed »emotional branding« as an alternative. However, this emotional branding led to many brands conveying nearly identical emotions. For example, BMW: »The Joy of Driving,« Seat: »Auto Emocìon,« Mercedes: »More Driving Pleasure,« McDonald’s: »I’m Loving It,« and Lee Jeans: »Live With Passion.”.

Newer branding approaches, such as brand experience, buzz marketing (generating excitement), or brand love, lead to greater diversity in positioning. However, they, too, are based on inauthentic brand attributes. Such branding strategies may work for private-label brands or low-involvement brands and lead to increased sales or more «Facebook likes.» However, they can never be used to create a cult brand, because a cult brand thrives on genuine «emotional attachment». To establish an emotional bond, the brand must fit into the consumer’s authentic cultural value system. For example, Corona stands for «relaxation on a Mexican beach,» Harley-Davidson for «freedom,» and The Body Shop for «protecting nature.» It is becoming increasingly necessary for brands—in addition to films, art, literature, and music—to strive for a certain cultural orientation or to make a certain cultural contribution. For this reason, drawing on the work of Douglas Holt (Harvard University) and Grant McCracken (Massachusetts Institute of Technology), I have developed the following Cultural Branding Model:

1. Description of the Prevailing Ideology

In every product category, there is a specific dominant ideology. The goal of this first step is to examine and describe this ideology. For a long time, the food industry was dominated by an ideology characterized by strong price sensitivity. The market entry of Aldi and Lidl, along with the launch of Migros Budget and Prix Garantie, further reinforced this ideology.

2. Identifying Cultural Change

The task now is to compare this existing ideology with the customers’ identity. The focus here is on determining to what extent society is satisfied with this prevailing ideology, desires change, or even rejects it. A certain subculture within our society rejected the prevailing ideology of the food industry. This cultural shift led to a value system centered on organic food, sustainable production, and fair trade. Countless such cultural shifts occur within a society; they can be triggered by technology (e.g., the Internet), the economy (e.g., the financial sector), social structure (e.g., an education craze), demographics (e.g., an aging population), social movements (e.g., opponents of nuclear power plants), mass media, or other factors.

3. Definition of Cultural Ideology

The task now is to align the branding with the identified cultural shift. The goal is to create a new ideology that serves as a guiding force in the context of cultural and social change. Ultimately, the ideology to be created is regarded as a brand’s value system—that is, a shared set of values with which consumers can identify. Knight and Bowerman—the founders of Nike—recognized a societal shift toward greater individuality in the 1970s. Team sports were losing their appeal in favor of running. They capitalized on this trend and created a new ideology: «The power of one’s own will is unbeatable»—or, as it became better known through the later slogan: «Just do it.» Every cultural ideology should have an antagonist (a brand or industry), meaning it must clearly distinguish itself from another ideology. Apple still rebels today against the complexity of IBM and Windows systems. Such clear positioning encourages consumers to identify with the brand. This self-identification, in turn, leads to greater loyalty. Thus, like-minded people find one another in brand communities (e.g., the Harley-Davidson Owners Group), build such communities, and live according to a specific value system. In such communities, brand myths are lived out and passed on. Ideally, brand myths are carried beyond the community and into the public sphere (such as during the Goruck Challenges).

4. Communicating the Ideology

A key phase of the Cultural Branding Model is its communicative implementation. No matter how great an idea may be, it is meaningless if it is not shared with others. For this reason, a separate phase is dedicated to the active and creative communication of the established ideology.

5. Establishing a Culture-Oriented Approach

According to the Cultural Branding Model, a cult brand should not maintain a consistent market presence for decades, but must embrace and respond to cultural changes. Consequently, every brand management team must be able to identify future cultural and social developments early on and distinguish real trends from passing fads. To do so, management must systematically monitor magazines, TV shows, online forums, blogs, selected Twitter accounts, etc.

Dimitri Wittwer

kultmarken
 Dimitri Wittwer (@thecultbrand) is a doctoral candidate and research assistant at the Institute for Marketing and Business Management at the University of Bern. He conducts research on cult brands in collaboration with international research partners from Concordia University in Montréal and Columbia University in New York. His book, *The Cultural Branding Model*, will be published at the end of the year.
 

More articles on the topic