Marriage of convenience or love affair?
Companies are generally satisfied with the services provided by their agency, as a new market study shows. However, it also points to difficulties and shows potential for improvement. This is because customers are quite open to a change.
Cost pressure, increasing competition and a changing media environment - the challenges for media and advertising agencies are manifold. Digitalization is also making the tasks of communication service providers more complex. What do companies expect from communication service providers in this changed environment? How satisfied are they with their agency? And what are the foundations of successful collaboration? These questions were addressed in the study "Advertising and media agencies today and tomorrow - a study from the customer's perspective", which was carried out by the Lucerne School of Business (HSLU-W) in cooperation with the ZHAW School of Management and Law on the initiative of the association of leading advertising, media and communication agencies, bsw leading swiss agencies (see box for further information and methodology of the study).
Satisfied and yet not loyal
The good news is that there is generally a high level of satisfaction with the work of the service providers. The companies surveyed attest to their good service quality. The agencies are seen as competent and reliable. The less good news is that customer loyalty is not quite as good. Even satisfied companies can imagine changing agencies. A successful past is not a sufficient guarantee for a shared future. This is a finding that is known from other industries in the service sector and is also confirmed by practical experience. "Today, at least in large corporations, 'procurement' plays a decisive or even the dominant role in agency evaluation," says Cornelia Harder, CEO Draftfcb/Lowe Zurich. The main issue here is the amount of the fee. High staff turnover is also not conducive to long-term business relationships. The frequent changes - especially on the agency side - reduce loyalty to an agency. If there is a change at management level, it is by no means certain whether the client still wants to work with the same service provider.
Agencies need to invest in customer loyalty measures, according to Anja Janoschka, professor at the Institute of Communication and Marketing at Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts (HSLU-W). "Service providers need to emphasize their contribution to success more and communicate their performance," advises the researcher and project manager. "Unfortunately, these things often get lost in the daily work pressure." For example, regular reporting or controlling can show that added value is being generated. This is because customers set the price in relation to the service provided, as the study also showed. Satisfaction depends heavily on whether the agency delivers what it promises. "Customer care is a people business. It's difficult without a personal relationship," says Urs Schneider, founder and owner of Mediaschneider. Among other things, the media agency relies on workshops in which the path is defined together with the customer and the agency's approach is explained. The surest way to retain a client, however, is through the USP: with services that others do not offer. Agence Trio has various tools for customer retention: a strategic meeting is held every year to gain a deeper insight into the company. Workshops are held to analyze data, develop ideas and draw perspectives. On the other hand, they try to strengthen the customer relationship through proactivity. "Our aim is to approach every customer at least three to four times a year with strategic ideas or creative suggestions without being asked," says Michael Kamm, CEO and owner.
Specialists or full service?
Companies are divided on the question of whether they want to work with many specialized agencies (e.g. digital agencies etc.) in the future or whether they prefer a full service. In the case of media agencies, the trend is clearly towards concentrating the budget on one agency. Clients want a provider that offers them media consulting, planning, buying, etc. for all media, both online and offline. Opinions differ among advertising agencies. While some clients still want to rely on the classic full-service agency, others plan to increasingly outsource their orders to different agencies in the future - whether within a network or to separate service providers. Draftfcb/Lowe Zurich and Agence Trio naturally emphasize the advantages of full service. "Companies that realize projects with many different agencies usually underestimate the increased internal and external coordination effort," Harder points out.
Agencies are challenged: They must master the entire range of media, regardless of whether they ultimately realize the orders internally or outsource them to specialists. This is secondary for clients. As long as the quality is right, clients are not interested in whether a service is provided by the agency itself or by external specialists. Added to this is the speed demanded by companies. "More and more industries and markets are exposed to higher speeds; marketing decisions are therefore increasingly being made according to short-term criteria," says Harder. This requires agencies to respond quickly to clients' needs - without neglecting brand management and continuity in communication. "The quality of an agency is reflected in its ability to solve problems in the short term without losing sight of the client's long-term goals." Customers can score points with initiative. In this respect, service providers could step on the gas a little more, as the study shows.
From the client's point of view, agencies may well act a little more proactively and make suggestions without being explicitly asked to do so. However, the perceived competence (which is not questioned) and the commitment of the management or owner are more decisive for companies than proactivity. "Top management or the owner play an important role in looking after the customer," says Janoschka. Companies see their role as that of the customer confirmed when top management makes its presence felt from time to time. They value the experience of the management and are convinced that their involvement will have a successful impact on the project results.
Weak point: willingness to provide service
The study identifies potential for improvement, particularly in the willingness to provide service. Apparently, agencies do not always succeed in giving customers the feeling that they are in good hands. The clients believe that agencies could still work on their friendliness. The prevailing pressure from day-to-day business is making itself felt. Not all companies have the impression that employees are able to answer their inquiries immediately. The workload from daily business is sometimes so great that resources are lacking when unexpected events occur. Clients also have doubts as to whether employees always receive enough support from their agency to get the job done well. Managers should make their employees aware of how important customer care work is and train them in dealing with customers, says Janoschka. The researcher understands that customer care is difficult in hectic situations and when deadlines are looming. However, it depends on how communication takes place. A "chopping and changing" mentality does not create understanding for the situation. "If a customer request cannot be met due to a lack of time, you have to explain why this is not possible."
The agencies surveyed take the results seriously. They want to train their employees even better and ensure that they receive the necessary support from their managers. "The study shows me that we need to invest even more in consulting," says Kamm. "The advisor is the eye of the needle through which everything passes. If contact with the customer is lost there, the competition will quickly arrive." Although advertising is becoming more and more digital, technical expertise is not enough. "The survey showed how important the relationship is. In the end, the human factor is the decisive factor."
Isabel Imper
The article in the layout of the print edition with all graphics can be found here as PDF.
