Even Swisscom against the Intelligence Services Act
The proposed Intelligence Service Act includes the possibility that data networks could also be spied on. However, telecommunications providers apparently do not want to act as assistants in espionage and eavesdropping.
In order to tap into the fiber optic cable networks, the Federal Intelligence Service (FIS) would need the help of Swiss telecommunications providers. They would have to forward the secretly obtained data streams to the spying center stationed in Zimmerwald BE, writes Schweiz am Sonntag. However, the telecommunications provider industry does not want to participate.
However, it is not only the telecommunications industry that is critical of the Intelligence Service Act. As Schweiz am Sonntag writes, twelve cantons have used the consultation process to express their concerns. The Basel government even warns of "serious encroachments on fundamental rights".
Swico, the trade association for digital Switzerland, to which more than 400 providers from the information and communication technology sectors belong, also opposes an expansion towards total surveillance, as is the case in the USA. According to Schweiz am Sonntag, even Swisscom, which is majority-owned by the state, is against the planned surveillance of fiber optic cable networks: The telecommunications giant believes that the concept of cable reconnaissance is still not mature enough. It also criticizes the fact that it is not known to what extent personal information will be collected, stored and evaluated. The Swiss Telecommunications Association Asut is of the same opinion: according to the association, it is imperative that there is sufficient evidence of the expense, proportionality, benefits and effectiveness before cable reconnaissance is enshrined in law.
The telecommunications industry is also afraid of damage to its image, writes Schweiz am Sonntag. This would be the case if it were to be denounced as an accomplice of the secret service.
The Swiss Federal Intelligence Service, on the other hand, has dismissed the concerns, according to Schweiz am Sonntag: it will handle the cable reconnaissance in such a way that it causes as little intrusion into privacy as possible.
