Responsive or adaptive?
It is well known that websites are increasingly being accessed via tablets and smartphones. What is less well known is how to address this reality with your own website. What decisions need to be made before optimizing a website for mobile devices?
There are two ways to optimize a website for mobile devices: adaptive web design and responsive web design. Before deciding on one of the two methods, the following questions need to be answered:
- Does the visitor access the website using both a mobile device and a laptop/desktop?
- Do website visitors via smartphone, tablet or laptop have the same requirements in terms of information content and design?
- Which interactions (filling out forms, etc.) should the tablet or smartphone user be able to carry out?
- What is more important: website use on a specific output device or a stringent design?
- How much time and money should go into the design and implementation of the website? How much in maintenance?
etc.
Web analytics data is helpful in the decision-making process. They document which devices (smartphones, tablets) visitors use to access the website, what they look at and where they leave the site. With these insights into the needs of the different types of visitors, the right decisions can be made.
Adaptive Web Design
If the information, design and navigation of the website are optimized for the device used, adaptive web design is in use. Mobile websites such as those of SBB, Google, Leo etc. are typical independent implementations of the website in Adaptive Web Design with an independent structure and design. Implementation in Adaptive Web Design is simple, and this method guarantees high performance. On the other hand, adaptive web design is inflexible and geared towards the display sizes of certain devices (iPad, iPhone). As long as the visitor uses exactly these devices, the display is optimal. If they use a Samsung tablet with a smaller display instead of an iPad, the output is no longer optimal. It should also be noted that the adaptive website requires a dedicated URL.
Responsive Web Design
Responsive web design is the optimal solution for websites whose entire content should be accessible on all devices without restrictions in a uniform design. Thanks to a flexible design, the website can adapt to any display size (see http://teixido.co) and can always be accessed via the same URL. This sustainable solution automatically covers the requirements of mobile devices with new display sizes. This in turn makes the design and implementation complex and time-consuming.
Prior needs assessment
The implementation of a website in Responsive or Adaptive Web Design is not always mandatory. The decision depends on the orientation and use of the website. It should also be taken into account that a website that has been implemented with a CMS (content management system) can be used to its full extent on a desktop, laptop or tablet. Whether the website should also be optimized for smartphones depends on its relevance for this user group.
Imre Sinka
