Will Google Glass win the hearts and minds?

The growing buzz around Google Glass illustrates how the mobile sector is evolving—and raises numerous questions. An article by Christoph J. Walther from the current print issue of *Werbewoche* (6/2013).

Apple led the way with the media hype surrounding the launch of new iPhones, and now Google is trying to emulate this example. The object that is set to arouse frenetic desire is called Google Glass: a mini screen is placed in front of the eye with a frame (with or without corrective lenses). Equipped in this way, you can easily access the internet at any time to make phone calls, start search queries by voice input, read new messages, take photos or videos and even have the world explained to you. In fact, nothing that couldn't be done with a modern smartphone, but in a different way. People who concentrate on their smartphone and swipe around on the screen isolate themselves in society and it feels somehow "emasculating", said Google co-founder Sergey Brin during an impromptu appearance at a TED conference at the end of February. He also wanted to get closer to the vision that anyone who needed information would no longer have to search for it, but would simply receive it when they needed it.

How "cool" are walking surveillance cameras?

However, unlike Apple's iPhone, whose aesthetics were convincing, the emerging data glasses bring with them some unfamiliar innovations, which is why many contemporaries are reacting negatively to them, and in some cases very strongly, as a glance at the numerous blog entries and comments reveals. It is clear that the launch of Google Glass will be accompanied by a multifaceted and far-reaching social discourse on sometimes fundamental social issues, such as how to deal with privacy in the age of ubiquitous and networked systems. The built-in camera and microphone, in particular, are causing a lot of controversy. This was already the case when cameras became ubiquitous with smartphones. However, it was still possible to recognize when someone was recording with it, and it was possible to react and intervene if necessary. With Glass, it is no longer possible to tell whether recordings are being made or not. If such recordings were only intended for the wearer's own use, the issue would probably cause fewer heated discussions. But cyber glasses don't come alone: Glass works (via Bluetooth) together with a smartphone, which in turn is connected to computers all over the world via data transmission (WiFi or GSM/UMTS/LTE). This is the only way to implement many of the "cool" applications that make data privacy advocates' blood run cold or boil (depending on their temperament). For example, tourists walking through a foreign city and having the sights explained to them via Glass and finding the trendy meeting places will transmit image and geodata to Google so that images can be recognized and evaluated. Critics complain that personal data (faces) of bystanders could also be analyzed and that such data could be stored for an uncontrolled period of time, even abroad. Glass wearers would thus become potential walking surveillance cameras, surpassing the worst ideas of Big Brother.

And so a closer look at Glass reveals numerous other areas, as smart glasses bring changes that are beneficial but unfamiliar. Many of them, such as the use of video cameras, will raise concerns among data protectionists. This also applies to Switzerland, where video surveillance by private individuals is regulated by the Federal Act on Data Protection and subject to numerous restrictions. The emerging debate about the use of Glass will not just be about legal or political issues, but also about social norms: Is it ok to meet someone in a one-on-one conversation with data glasses on? Can you ask such a person to refrain from wearing them? What if the other person is visually impaired and (also) uses the glasses as a visual aid? Can Glass be used in road traffic? According to Google, Glass has "enormous potential" to improve safety on our roads and reduce the number of accidents. However, there is already a bill in the US state of West Virginia to change the law to prohibit the use of devices such as Glass on the roads. It is therefore clear that politicians will also have to deal with Glass. Politicians in particular could be among the most frequent users of data glasses, which will be viewed differently in the foreseeable future: For example, in debates (think of an arena round), will they only use Glass to access a few notes they have written themselves, or will they constantly receive new arguments from their advisors and lobbyists?

No advertising on Glass?

Google is taking on a pioneering role with Glass and will attract most of the criticism. This may be courageous or naïve - but it would be wrong to weigh the issue down with Google hatred. After all, digital glasses are not just an allure of Google bosses. Rumors and speculations are circulating that Microsoft will launch a similar product on the market in 2014, and in China, the largest search engine operator Baidu has announced that it is developing a similar product with Baidu Eye. And Facebook boss Marc Zuckerberg is reported to be eager to use Google Glass and has already set up his own development department for this purpose. It is therefore not surprising that the first media companies, such as the New York Times, have started to prepare their content specifically for Glass. According to initial information on Google's program interface, it is possible to subscribe to information streams that are divided into so-called cards, which can also contain rich media such as images. Cards can be combined into bundles, and options such as "share" or "read aloud" allow various interactions. As hardly anyone will want to consume large texts, the main focus is on headlines so that users can keep up to date with the latest news throughout the day whenever they have time. What interests them can be sent to their own tablet, for example, where it can be consumed in detail later.

Anyone who thinks about advertising via Glass and starts dreaming about it will first have to take note of Google's assertion that there will be no advertising on Glass. In any case, it is easy to imagine that a news offering for Glass could also contain cards with advertising messages. These may cover the entire card or just part of it and will probably always be tailored to the profile of the respective user. However, there are also advertising fantasies about the use of Glass that should be viewed with skepticism, at least for the time being. For example, discount coupons to entice customers into the store they are walking past. Or using image analysis to show where to buy the dress or tie you have just come across. Or transform the real world into a gaming environment (branded entertainment using augmented reality). Such things will probably remain fiction for some time to come because most users will hardly be willing to share their location data or use their precious data transfer credit to continuously transmit video data to Google so that it can be analyzed and used for profile matching to create advertising messages that are displayed to users on the Glass screen. In addition, many websites, even those of major brands, are not yet optimized for smartphones and therefore adaptation for smart glasses will only be considered when there is a prospect that the additional effort will be worthwhile.

This assumes that smart glasses will quickly become mainstream. Glass enthusiasts point out that new technologies are catching on with the public faster and faster. The smartphone boom, for example, has happened ten times faster than the PC revolution in the 1980s. It remains to be seen whether Glass will become a hit and when the devices will go on sale in Switzerland (in the USA, this is expected to happen before the end of this year). But one thing is clear: data glasses will become an increasingly important topic in the coming months. And so it will be interesting to keep an eye on Glass and observe how these aspects will develop: Will Glass be a success for Google, or will it damage its own brand? How (if at all) will Glass and its ilk appear on the Swiss market, and what debates will this trigger? What specific opportunities will data glasses create for media companies and advertising?

Christoph J. Walther

google-glass
The New York Times was the first media company to demonstrate how Google Glass can be used in the media sector: Beautifully presented headlines are designed to keep users up to date with current events throughout the day.

abonnent-werden

 

Will Google Glass win the hearts and minds?

The growing buzz around Google Glass shows how mobile technology is evolving—and raises numerous questions. By Christoph J. Walther

Apple led the way with the media hype surrounding the launch of new iPhones, and now Google is trying to emulate this example. The object that is set to arouse frenetic desire is called Google Glass: a mini screen is placed in front of the eye with a frame (with or without corrective lenses). Equipped in this way, you can easily access the internet at any time to make phone calls, start search queries by voice input, read new messages, take photos or videos and even have the world explained to you. In fact, nothing that couldn't be done with a modern smartphone, but in a different way. People who concentrate on their smartphone and swipe around on the screen isolate themselves in society and it feels somehow "emasculating", said Google co-founder Sergey Brin during an impromptu appearance at a TED conference at the end of February. He also wanted to get closer to the vision that anyone who needed information would no longer have to search for it, but would simply receive it when they needed it.

How "cool" are walking surveillance cameras?

However, unlike Apple's iPhone, whose aesthetics were convincing, the emerging data glasses bring with them some unfamiliar innovations, which is why many contemporaries are reacting negatively to them, and in some cases very strongly, as a glance at the numerous blog entries and comments reveals. It is clear that the launch of Google Glass will be accompanied by a multifaceted and far-reaching social discourse on sometimes fundamental social issues, such as how to deal with privacy in the age of ubiquitous and networked systems. The built-in camera and microphone, in particular, are causing a lot of controversy. This was already the case when cameras became ubiquitous with smartphones. However, it was still possible to recognize when someone was recording with it, and it was possible to react and intervene if necessary. With Glass, it is no longer possible to tell whether recordings are being made or not. If such recordings were only intended for the wearer's own use, the issue would probably cause fewer heated discussions. But cyber glasses don't come alone: Glass works (via Bluetooth) together with a smartphone, which in turn is connected to computers all over the world via data transmission (WiFi or GSM/UMTS/LTE). This is the only way to implement many of the "cool" applications that make data privacy advocates' blood run cold or boil (depending on their temperament). For example, tourists walking through a foreign city and having the sights explained to them via Glass and finding the trendy meeting places will transmit image and geodata to Google so that images can be recognized and evaluated. Critics complain that personal data (faces) of bystanders could also be analyzed and that such data could be stored for an uncontrolled period of time, even abroad. Glass wearers would thus become potential walking surveillance cameras, surpassing the worst ideas of Big Brother.

And so a closer look at Glass reveals numerous other areas, as smart glasses bring changes that are beneficial but unfamiliar. Many of them, such as the use of video cameras, will raise concerns among data protectionists. This also applies to Switzerland, where video surveillance by private individuals is regulated by the Federal Act on Data Protection and subject to numerous restrictions. The emerging debate about the use of Glass will not just be about legal or political issues, but also about social norms: Is it ok to meet someone in a one-on-one conversation with data glasses on? Can you ask such a person to refrain from wearing them? What if the other person is visually impaired and (also) uses the glasses as a visual aid? Can Glass be used in road traffic? According to Google, Glass has "enormous potential" to improve safety on our roads and reduce the number of accidents. However, there is already a bill in the US state of West Virginia to change the law to prohibit the use of devices such as Glass on the roads. It is therefore clear that politicians will also have to deal with Glass. Politicians in particular could be among the most frequent users of data glasses, which will be viewed differently in the foreseeable future: For example, in debates (think of an arena round), will they only use Glass to access a few notes they have written themselves, or will they constantly receive new arguments from their advisors and lobbyists?

No advertising on Glass?

Google is taking on a pioneering role with Glass and will attract most of the criticism. This may be courageous or naïve - but it would be wrong to weigh the issue down with Google hatred. After all, digital glasses are not just an allure of Google bosses. Rumors and speculations are circulating that Microsoft will launch a similar product on the market in 2014, and in China, the largest search engine operator Baidu has announced that it is developing a similar product with Baidu Eye. And Facebook boss Marc Zuckerberg is reported to be eager to use Google Glass and has already set up his own development department for this purpose. It is therefore not surprising that the first media companies, such as the New York Times, have started to prepare their content specifically for Glass. According to initial information on Google's program interface, it is possible to subscribe to information streams that are divided into so-called cards, which can also contain rich media such as images. Cards can be combined into bundles, and options such as "share" or "read aloud" allow various interactions. As hardly anyone will want to consume large texts, the main focus is on headlines so that users can keep up to date with the latest news throughout the day whenever they have time. What interests them can be sent to their own tablet, for example, where it can be consumed in detail later.

Anyone who thinks about advertising via Glass and starts dreaming about it will first have to take note of Google's assertion that there will be no advertising on Glass. In any case, it is easy to imagine that a news offering for Glass could also contain cards with advertising messages. These may cover the entire card or just part of it and will probably always be tailored to the profile of the respective user. However, there are also advertising fantasies about the use of Glass that should be viewed with skepticism, at least for the time being. For example, discount coupons to entice customers into the store they are walking past. Or using image analysis to show where to buy the dress or tie you have just come across. Or transform the real world into a gaming environment (branded entertainment using augmented reality). Such things will probably remain fiction for some time to come because most users will hardly be willing to share their location data or use their precious data transfer credit to continuously transmit video data to Google so that it can be analyzed and used for profile matching to create advertising messages that are displayed to users on the Glass screen. In addition, many websites, even those of major brands, are not yet optimized for smartphones and therefore adaptation for smart glasses will only be considered when there is a prospect that the additional effort will be worthwhile.

This assumes that smart glasses will quickly become mainstream. Glass enthusiasts point out that new technologies are catching on with the public faster and faster. The smartphone boom, for example, has happened ten times faster than the PC revolution in the 1980s. It remains to be seen whether Glass will become a hit and when the devices will go on sale in Switzerland (in the USA, this is expected to happen before the end of this year). But one thing is clear: data glasses will become an increasingly important topic in the coming months. And so it will be interesting to keep an eye on Glass and observe how these aspects will develop: Will Glass be a success for Google, or will it damage its own brand? How (if at all) will Glass and its ilk appear on the Swiss market, and what debates will this trigger? What specific opportunities will data glasses create for media companies and advertising?

Christoph J. Walther

google-glass
The New York Times was the first media company to demonstrate how Google Glass can be used in the media sector: Beautifully presented headlines are designed to keep users up to date with current events throughout the day.
 

More articles on the topic