Swiss Brand Impact Study by Facebook: Encouraging results

How does mobile video advertising work? For the first time in Switzerland, Facebook has conducted a brand impact study. A conversation about the results with Paul Wiedmeier (Facebook), Christoph Timm (Swisscom) and Thierry Pool (Credit Suisse).

Facebook has been working intensively for a long time on investigating the impact of mobile video advertising in order to be able to adequately advise advertisers from different industries. Together with well-known companies - including Credit Suisse and Swisscom - the first brand impact study for Switzerland has now been realized. Corresponding studies pursue the goal of finding out whether the apps and services of the Facebook family contribute to a measurable incremental brand impact.

For the meta-study, Facebook conducted 17 brand lift tests in six different industries in Switzerland. Participating brands include Danone, Swisscom, Credit Suisse, Audi, UPC, WIR Bank, Mobiliar and Zürcher Kantonalbank. In total, campaigns of brands from eight different industries were analyzed: Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG), Financial Services, Telecommunications, E-commerce, Automotive, Luxury Goods and Retail. The campaigns studied ran for an average of four and a half weeks last year. All campaigns were optimized for reach, brand awareness or video views.

The results: Significant increases in ad recall were demonstrated 70 percent of the time, with an average increase of 8.1 percentage points. Assets that follow the creative principles optimized for mobile have an average of 4 percentage points higher ad recall than assets that are not optimized for our platforms. The most efficient cost per thousand (CPM, average CHF 3.32) was achieved by optimizing for brand awareness in combination with automatic placements.

Two of the first Swiss advertisers to participate in the meta-study are Credit Suisse and Swisscom. The results at Credit Suisse: Advertising recall was increased by +5.4 percentage points, awareness by +1.3 percentage points. A target group of 1.15 million people was reached.

At Swisscom, the Attribute Rating was increased by +8.4 percentage points, with costs per lift amounting to 0.56 Swiss francs. One million people were reached.

(From left) Paul Wiedmeier, Client Partner Facebook; Christoph Timm, SVP Marketing Communications, Swisscom and Thierry Pool, Global Director Digital & Data Marketing, Credit Suisse.

What those responsible have to say about the results

Christoph Timm, SVP Marketing Communications, Swisscom; Thierry Pool, Global Director Digital & Data Marketing, Credit Suisse and Paul Wiedmeier, Client Partner Facebook comment on the results.

 

Werbewoche.ch: Do the results meet your expectations, quantitatively and qualitatively?

Paul Wiedmeier: With the first study of its kind in Switzerland, we were able to gain both strong and insightful insights together with our partners. It is exciting to see how Facebook and Instagram can be used to increase brand metrics across industries. With partners such as Swisscom, Credit Suisse, Audi, Danone, UPC, Wir Bank, Zürcher Kantonalbank, and Mobiliar, the study included participants from eight different industries, underscoring the significance of the findings.

Quantitatively, thanks to Facebook and Instagram, we saw an average increase in recall (ad recall) of 8.1 percentage points - a value that is above the European average. In addition, we know that campaigns that achieve high recall are twice as likely to increase purchase intent, which is why this metric is so critical.

Qualitatively, the study was a valuable opportunity for our partners to put hypothesis-driven testing and learning into action. Many partners have taken the study results as an opportunity to incorporate the insights gained into future campaigns and to optimize the impact on brand metrics in a data-driven and ongoing way.

 

Is advertising on Facebook simply more effective - or do they see even more Advantages?

Paul Wiedmeier: The core advantages are certainly reach, targeting, brand safety, agility, and measurability. Facebook is an attractive channel simply because of its strong reach. Moreover, because we are a people-based platform, advertisers can map customer segments without wastage, whether via language settings or using CRM data. This enables a seamless transition from branding to performance marketing by means of retargeting or dynamic ads, for example. We have also invested a lot in the topic of brand safety and offer our partners numerous control options with so-called publisher allow or block lists, among other things. In addition, campaigns on Facebook and Instagram can be planned or canceled at very short notice, which offers great leeway in times of agility necessitated by the pandemic. Last but not least, measurability is certainly a crucial point to mention: Every centime advertisers spend on our platforms can be analyzed for effectiveness, whether in building brand metrics or directly in sales.

 

What was the interesting insight or surprise for you?

Paul Wiedmeier: It is particularly interesting to see the enormous importance of creative. Mobile-optimized creative that follows our best practices achieved on average a four percentage point higher increase in recall (ad recall). In other words, advertising media that present their brand immediately and make the core message clear in the first three seconds, that work with text and do without sound, and that work playfully with a clear visual language simply work much better. Both Credit Suisse with its CSX campaign and Swisscom with its blue campaign are good examples of this.

Some people will certainly be surprised by the attractive costs of brand building on Facebook and Instagram: On average, it cost only 53 centimes to incrementally increase the recall value of a person. This is a clear indicator of the independent contribution Facebook and Instagram make to brand building in the media mix.

 

For both Swisscom - with the launch of the Blue entertainment offering - and Credit Suisse - with the launch of the CSX digital bank - the campaigns that took part in the study were strategically important initiatives. What is your conclusion?

Thierry Pool: We are very satisfied with the launch of CSX. The target group of our digital offering CSX obviously moves strongly in the digital channels, and from this point of view we were able to address a target group that is highly relevant for us in a very targeted and correspondingly successful way. Apart from that, it's not as if the campaign has been stopped - it's much more the case that it's continuing with an always-on approach and will soon take off to new heights.

Christoph Timm: We are satisfied. We successfully launched our new entertainment offering under the blue brand. Naturally, we chose a balanced media mix for this. In times of home offices and limited mobility, online channels are becoming even more important. We have taken this into account. Social media, and Facebook in particular, have a firm place in our planning of measures. We appreciate the large reach and the possibilities to define the target group. Our own market research also confirms this, so I would call it a successful launch campaign.

 

How do they see the continued use of Facebook?

Christoph Timm: Facebook, and social media as a whole, is an established part of our media mix. Topic-specifically, of course, there are specifics that need to be considered. We can't use every channel for every one of our goals, but there has been a change in recent years, especially on social media channels. Whereas we used to mainly do community building to build our organic reach, we now go live with significantly more marketing topics. We don't do this on pure hunches, but we see that it works - users are more receptive to marketing messages. We see that the target group has matured, so it also brings a certain purchasing power. On the other hand, Facebook is no longer the first place we go when we want to reach a young target group - that's the other side of the coin. But that's what Instagram is for. But before this is misunderstood: We are now not using Facebook exclusively as a sales channel. We are constantly developing our social media strategy and adapting it as necessary. Reaching our community with appealing, original and surprising content plays an extremely important role.

 

If you use your budgets more for Facebook in the future - will you then use other, classic advertising channels less in the future - and if so, which ones?

Thierry Pool: It is doubly difficult to look to the future at the moment: If there are further lockdowns, more money will inevitably flow from OOH channels into advertising visible in the home (office). In principle, however, we rely on an aligned campaign across many channels anyway. The CSX campaign on Facebook has certainly benefited from the fact that we are visibly perceived on other channels with the same messages and image worlds. A statement on the development of individual channels would be speculative.

 

How important do you consider Facebook - or other social media platforms - as a community and feedback channel for your brand?

Christoph Timm: As already mentioned, our use of Facebook has several goals. A central point is not only to play on the community with flat promo messages. Of course, we also listen to the reactions and take the feedback to heart. We want to meet people at eye level, so for us it's part of our job to listen, but also to answer. We go to great lengths to ensure that as far as possible no inquiry goes unanswered Trustworthiness and commitment are two of our Swisscom values, and this naturally also applies on social media.

 

How important is Facebook compared to other channels and media?

Thierry Pool: We benefit greatly from the close cooperation with Facebook, but also with other channels and - ultimately - they all have their advantages and disadvantages. But the ability to innovate and the almost endless selection of best practice examples from all over the world inspire us to develop our advertising approaches further, not only in the creative sense, but also via the optimization of playout and the strong focus on smartphones.

Christoph Timm: That depends, but I wouldn't promise anything "in general". Yes, we see the current developments with regard to audio and video and we are also actively testing here to leverage this potential. But this always follows along the goals to be achieved. If we want to convey a short, concise message, the almost boring, static formats have established themselves and an additionally produced video does not necessarily promise better performance. Last but not least, we also depend on what new formats are available. We are always curious to test new formats and to question existing ones.

More articles on the topic