Social media: Federal Council wants to plug legal loopholes

In the Federal Council’s view, the problem with the legal regulation of social media platforms is not a lack of rules, but rather their enforcement. Foreign internet giants are only subject to Swiss law to a limited extent.

At the request of Parliament, the Federal Council has comprehensively outlined the legal challenges in connection with social networks on the internet in a 90-page report. On Wednesday, the government decided to tackle the individual legal loopholes identified over the next few years, as announced by the Department of the Environment, Transport, Energy and Communications (DETEC). However, the Federal Council is in no hurry. In principle, it believes that the rules of the analog age can be transferred to the digital age. Offensive comments on blogs can be prosecuted, criminal acts such as hardcore pornography are also prohibited on the Internet and the Data Protection Act sets guidelines for the handling of user data. However, practice puts these findings into perspective: The Federal Council states that it is uncertain whether private individuals will be able to enforce their legal claims against social networks. "Even the existence of a legally binding ruling by a Swiss court does not guarantee that it will be enforced abroad."

Free - but not free of charge

The Federal Council identifies fundamental problems with data protection. These are the same issues that repeatedly lead to discussions at European level: For example, the fact that many users lack awareness of what happens to their data. Social networks offer their services free of charge and earn their money by selling users' personal data. Other topics include the lack of user control over their data, the right to be forgotten on the non-forgetting Internet, facial recognition software, the creation of personality profiles and the transfer of user data from one social network to another.

Waiver of specific social media rules

According to the Federal Council, a working group dealing with the revision of the Data Protection Act is looking into whether there is a need to regulate such issues. The Federal Department of Justice and Police (FDJP) is to submit proposals to the Federal Council by the end of 2014. The government cites the obligation to have "data protection-friendly" default settings as an example of a possible regulation. This means that a platform should set restrictive options by default. Users should not have to search for and set these themselves. However, the Federal Council is already warning against over-regulation. As the internet is changing rapidly, premature action could lead to unintended effects. It also wants to keep an eye on international developments, as most communications are cross-border.

Liability of blog providers

The Federal Council wants to tackle the liability regulations for internet providers. It is thus reacting to a ruling by the Federal Supreme Court, which had to judge the case of a blog on the website of the Geneva daily newspaper Tribune de Genève. The court ruled that the newspaper must assume liability for posts on the blog that violate personal rights. This was met with criticism, as such liability is excluded or regulated more restrictively in the EU. However, the Federal Council has left open the direction in which the civil liability of internet providers or operators of social media platforms should be regulated.

No special law

While it wants to clarify many open questions in more detail, the Federal Council has clearly rejected a special social media law. Viola Amherd (CVP/VS), whose postulate triggered the report, brought such a law into play. She compared social media with radio and television, for which a law exists. In the view of the Federal Council, the same need does not exist for social media. (SDA)

Image: hae/wewo
 

More articles on the topic