The end of the big regional newspapers
It's been a long time since there's been as much activity in the media industry as there has been in recent weeks.
With the sale of the Washington Post to Jeff Bezos, the Boston Globe to billionaire John Henry and a traditional centerpiece of Springer AG to the Funke Group, speculation and misjudgments ran rampant with each of these transactions. The journalistic handling of the megadeals shows once again how much damage is being done to an industry that reports on everything and everyone in the world, but thinks it can easily do without competent observers of its own profession in its editorial offices.
The legacy of the company's founder was being "betrayed", for example, according to many voices on the Springer-Funke deal, and with the sale of Hamburger Abendblatt, Berliner Morgenpost and Hörzu, the larger of the two publishing houses was "bidding farewell to journalism". Those who spread such nonsense probably didn't ask themselves how a gifted publisher like Axel Springer would have reacted to the digitalization of the industry, and also showed that they didn't understand the most important momentum of the Internet: "The winner takes it all" - this principle applies much more strongly on the Internet than in the real economy.
Microsoft, Google, Facebook and Amazon are the most prominent examples of this, but the principle also applies to submarkets such as the online classifieds business with car, real estate or partnership ads, as well as to news sites: If you want to know what's going on in the world, you will probably click on cnn.com, nytimes.com or theguardian.com in the English-speaking world, and on newsnet.ch or nzz.ch in Switzerland. Those who want to find out what's happening around the corner from home generally have local or hyperlocal websites at their disposal. In between, the large regional newspapers are being squeezed out if they are not already part of a news network such as newsnet. ch.
In the "good old" print era, they for their part usually plundered advertising customers as highly profitable monopolists - be it the advertising industry, the small advertiser looking for a new girlfriend or someone walking their poodle. We now know that these days of regional newspaper monopolies are gone for good: "Newspapers will have to finance themselves without ads in the future," Spiegel (no. 32/2013) recently quoted the head of one of the major media agencies as saying. If we analyze the megadeals together, it is noticeable that all of the newspaper titles sold are large regional papers - even the Washington Post ultimately never progressed beyond this status as the US capital's newspaper, despite the national reach of its website. It is to be expected that the new owners will commit all the cruelties towards their editorial teams that seemed unthinkable in houses such as the Washington Post Co, the New York Times Co, which has bled to death at the Boston Globe, and Springer AG - because they were all known as employers for a certain nobility, while at least in Germany both the Funke Group (formerly WAZ Group) and Jeff Bezos' Amazon are already known for squeezing their employees to the utmost and, if necessary, throwing them out the door without much ado.
Regional editorial offices are systemically relevant
You can't blame companies like the New York Times Co. and Springer AG for getting rid of their regional newspaper ballast. They too only have a digital future if they join forces and relegate their competitors with national news sites such as nytimes.com, welt.de or bild.de to the back burner instead of competing with their own regional newspaper websites.
However, we cannot and must not be indifferent to what happens to regional newspaper editorial offices. In the past, a lot of unnecessary double and triple work was done there. The second and third sports reporter covering the same football match from the same publishing house, for example, could be rationalized away without harming the community or journalism. On the other hand, large, functioning regional editorial offices - as Heribert Prantl, member of the editorial board of Süddeutsche Zeitung, has recently pointed out - are "systemically relevant" for journalism and democracy. Without its research capacity and without its institutional memory, the "fourth estate" is in danger of losing its ability to function. This is because the national giants of the industry are ultimately dependent on the supplies of regional newspapers and no longer have their own local correspondents in every major city. Even where these still exist, such one-man offices do not replace local editorial offices, but at best exploit their work more or less reliably nationwide.
However, if journalism no longer performs its control function with a division of labor and across the board, there is a growing danger that corruption and abuse of power will spread rapidly in politics and business. As Joseph Pulitzer already knew, those in power have far more respect for investigative, independent journalists than for public prosecutors and ordinary courts. Where such journalists no longer exist, political populists and populist media moguls are very likely to work together to undermine democracy - Berlusconi and Erdogan send their regards.
Stephan Russ-Mohl
