Communications industry is "contract-resistant"
Written contracts prevent disputes. By Ueli Grüter
Practice shows that in the communications industry, orders are often processed on an ongoing basis without written contracts, often simply by order confirmation. The parties, the clients, the agencies, but also their freelancers, are not aware of the legal risk. Time and again, this leads to costly and nerve-wracking disputes. The effort required for clear contractual conditions would not be particularly great.
If graphic works or the realization of advertising campaigns are commissioned, it must be regulated in particular who owns which rights to these works or which rights are transferred to the client. In addition, the question often arises in practice as to whether graphic work and advertising campaigns are used several times (e.g. this spring and then again in the spring of the following year) and whether they may be modified. If so, it must also be regulated whether a fee is to be paid to the contractor again. The question always arises as to whether rights have only been licensed or purchased. In case of doubt, a license should be assumed. In addition, when freelancers are brought in, it must be ensured that they transfer all rights that the contractor subsequently transfers to their client; in other words, harmonious licensing is required.
It is understandable that creative professionals do not want to have to deal with legal issues again and again. It is therefore advisable to draw up well thought-out general terms and conditions (GTC) that have been checked by a lawyer and that can then be used again and again without any changes. Such general terms and conditions should generally be clearly indicated on the contractor's homepage. In addition, GTCs are best sent with an offer or at the latest with the order confirmation. A prerequisite for the applicability of the GTC is that the customer was able to take note of them before concluding the contract. GTC can of course also be adapted to the specific circumstances and at the customer's request. This is done within the framework of an individual contract, which may only comprise one A4 page.
Zurich district attorney's office cracks down on sweepstakes
Migros fined for violation of lottery law
In the Advertising Week of January 17, 2013, I warned that the Lottery and Betting Commission (Comlot, www.comlot.ch) was taking more rigorous action against violations of the Lottery Act in competitions and prize draws. Now it has struck again, and the Zurich Statthalteramt has fined Migros a four-figure sum for the "MegaWin" and "Die Lose sind los!" competitions. This was because although it was possible to take part in the Migros competitions free of charge, those who took part for free did not have the same chances as Migros customers. Other similar proceedings are currently pending, including against Coop competitions.
According to Article 1 of the Lotteries Act, a lottery has four cumulative characteristics: Payment of a stake or conclusion of a legal transaction, pecuniary advantage as a prize, systematic nature of the implementation and determination of the winners by chance, e.g. by drawing. This actually makes it clear how to avoid a conflict with the Lotteries Act and Comlot when organizing a competition or lottery: You make sure that one of the characteristics of a lottery is not present in the competition or raffle. As a rule, it is easiest to guarantee all interested parties a free entry into the competition. However, this must be clearly communicated and be available without obstacles or simply. In addition, all participants must have the same chance of winning, even if they participate for free.
Ueli Grüter LL.M., attorney at law, Grüter Schneider & Partner AG, Zurich/Lucerne, is a lecturer in communications law at the Lucerne University of Applied Sciences and Arts and co-editor of the book Kommunikationsrecht.ch. He comments on practical legal issues in advertising once a month in Werbewoche. Questions for the Werbewoche legal expert at [email protected].
