Swiss Post cannot protect DIE POST as a trademark

What can you register as a trademark? It should not be descriptive, but as imaginative as possible. By Ueli Grüter

Once again, the Federal Administrative Court has ruled that Swiss Post cannot protect the name DIE POST, as it previously did POST, as a trademark for its core business, the transportation of letters and parcels, as both the name POST and DIE POST are descriptive of postal services in the narrow sense and therefore not distinctive, which is the legal meaning of a trademark. Moreover, the designations POST and DIE POST are terms that must also be available to other service providers for the transportation of letters and parcels, as there are no alternative designations.

The Trademark Protection Act does not positively define how a trademark must be in order to be protected. The law lists absolute and relative grounds for exclusion from trademark protection. In any case, a sign that belongs to the public domain, such as individual letters, numbers, general shapes and colors, cannot be protected as a trademark. Such signs can exceptionally be registered as trademarks if they are very strongly associated with a company and there are alternatives for other companies. Swiss Post, for example, was not able to register the designations POST and DIE POST as trademarks, but was able to register the typical "Postgelb" as a color trademark. As a rule, this requires a long period of use, a high level of recognition among the public and a strong association with the company. It is also absolutely impossible to register shapes that constitute the essence of a product and shapes of the product or packaging that are technically necessary. A sign that is registered as a trademark must also not be misleading. For example, a TITLIS trademark is restricted to "goods from Switzerland", as Swiss mountains stand for Swiss products according to case law. Finally, trademarks must not violate public order, morality or applicable law. For example, the Federal Administrative Court refused to allow the singer Madonna to register the name "Madonna" as a trademark, as "Madonna" on goods of any kind was likely to offend the religious feelings of Catholic Christians.

Relative to an already registered trademark, the ground for refusal is that a trademark cannot be registered if it is identical to an existing trademark in the register and is to be filed for the same goods or services, or for similar goods or services if there is a likelihood of confusion, or a similar trademark for the same or similar goods and services if there is a likelihood of confusion. In this case, the owner of the earlier trademark can file an opposition against the new trademark. If he does not do so, it is also possible that two identical or similar trademarks for identical or similar goods or services are entered in the register.

In positive terms, this means that for a trademark to be successfully registered, it should be as far removed from the public domain as possible, not descriptive of the goods or services used and therefore as imaginative as possible. A good example of this is the Google trademark. Before filing a trademark application, it is also necessary to search whether an identical or similar trademark has already been registered for identical or similar goods and services. Some of the possible online search tools can be found on the platform www.kommunikationsrecht.ch*. For important projects, a trademark attorney should be consulted, who can be found on the homepage of the Swiss Federal Institute of Intellectual Property www.ige.ch **.

Ueli GrüterLL.M., attorney at law, Grüter Schneider & Partner AG, Zurich, is a lecturer in communications law and co-editor of the book Kommunikationsrecht.ch. He comments on practical legal issues in advertising once a month in Werbewoche. Questions for the Werbewoche legal expert at [email protected].

www.kommunikationsrecht.ch/links.php
www.ige.ch/marken/schutz-in-der-schweiz/markenberater
 

More articles on the topic