Intellectual property law - occupational therapy for lawyers?
How trademarks and patents benefit even non-lawyers, and what happens if you don't have a trademark or a patent. By Ueli Grüter
Legal disputes over trademarks and patents are more present in the media than ever before. This makes non-lawyers curious, but they are also somehow weary of the matter. The protection of intellectual property is not natural and has only existed in its current form since the end of the 19th century. There are entire continents that still believe that creations and innovations belong to everyone and should not be monopolized. It was only through concessions in agricultural trade that these countries were persuaded to protect or better protect intellectual property on their territory. Intellectual property rights are not an invention of lawyers, but of economists and politicians. Whenever patent protection is to be restricted in Switzerland, it is not the companies' lawyers who stand up against it, but their managers. Because protecting innovation is protecting investment. This is confirmed by someone who has become enormously wealthy through innovation, but for whom the focus has always been on innovation, not money. Steve Jobs is convinced that the economic basis of Apple is intellectual property and that there would have been no incentive for Apple to develop products if they had not been protected. As soon as the protection of intellectual property was no longer guaranteed, creative companies would disappear or not be founded in the first place*.
Intellectual property rights give a company the opportunity to amortize its investments in creations and innovations without interruption for a certain period of time. In general, patents are protected for 20 years, designs for 25 years from the date of filing and copyrights for 70 years after the death of the author. The trademark can even enjoy perpetual protection if it is renewed every 10 years; this is why the question of the validity of the design trademark, rather than the patents, is particularly hot in the dispute over the Nespresso coffee capsule.
No one is forced to register a trademark, patent or design. Copyright protection arises even without registration, i.e. completely free of charge, at the moment the work is created, worldwide. With trademarks, patents and designs, however, you run the risk that someone else who registers will restrict you in the commercial use of your innovation. You can continue to use an unregistered trademark, but only to the same extent as before. With patents, there are no problems if you were on the relevant market earlier than the person who applied for a patent for the same innovation, as this is then invalid because it is prior art. The same applies analogously to the design.
Intellectual property rights are instruments for the protection of creations and innovations. Whether you make use of them depends in particular on how much you invest in them or will invest in them in the future. On the one hand, intellectual property rights allow you to prohibit others from using your creations and innovations commercially without your consent; on the other hand, they protect you from others with better rights prohibiting the use of your own innovations. It is an entrepreneurial and not a legal decision whether to make use of innovation protection.
*Walter Isaacson, Steve Jobs, New York 2011
Ueli GrüterLL.M., attorney at law, Grüter Schneider & Partner AG, Zurich, is a lecturer in communications law and co-editor of the book Kommunikationsrecht.ch. He comments on practical legal issues in advertising once a month in Werbewoche. Questions for the Werbewoche legal expert at [email protected].
