What you can do about 70 percent wastage
If the latest studies are to be believed, marketing campaigns result in wastage on the order of 70 percent. That’s a huge and costly figure that no one wants. Christoph Spengler of Accelerom explains in his guest article what can be done about it.

Scatter loss is defined as "the proportion of people reached who do not belong to the target group". This widespread definition dates back to a time when people still had printer's ink on their fingers after reading a newspaper. Tempi passati! Today, much deeper insights are needed to successfully manage market cultivation. For success to really materialize, the attention of (potential) customers must be captured, impulses for action must be given, a relationship must be established and, last but not least, they must be motivated to buy.
Scatter loss doesn't only exist in advertising
Scatter loss can occur along the entire customer journey - at both analog and digital touchpoints. For me, all measures and investments that do not have the intended effect and ultimately do not make the necessary contribution to successful market cultivation must also be included.
More and more total failures
Scatter loss has always existed and will continue to exist in the future. The key questions are therefore: How can wastage be minimized? How can the impact of market development measures be maximized? What is surprising, however, is the fact that there are more and more total failures in market communication. The main causes are currently:
- Lack of interest on the part of the target persons: Communication content and media used meet with little interest and are weakly activating,
- Too little communication pressure: The market development measures are not perceived by the target groups,
- inadequate support up to the point of purchase: customers are merely inspired, but not guided to purchase, and
- Inconsistent brand presence in the customer journey: target groups, touchpoints and content are not sufficiently coordinated.
Not all reach is the same
On the mission to "combat wastage", it is worth taking a closer look at the key figure "reach". Here is a common paraphrase: "Reach is the number of people who are reached by an advertising medium or an advertising medium." The definition is not really precise and does not take into account actual customer behavior.
Traditional advertising, such as advertisements, posters and TV commercials, almost exclusively attract the attention of target groups passively. In contrast, more and more (potential) customers are actively gathering information - for example by googling, configuring a product or formulating an inquiry. Two completely different types of reach can be derived from this: passive and active reach. Irrespective of this, in connection with the distortions and errors, the question must be asked as to whether planning with reach and contact opportunities is still helpful, as the planned values reflect reality less and less.
Due to the imprecision of the traditional key figure "reach", misinterpretations are the order of the day, which has a significant impact on success management and ultimately also on wastage. In our more than ten years of consulting experience, it has been confirmed many times that an extremely large potential for success can be tapped if these inaccuracies in the reach values are consciously corrected. One or two additional OTS to increase advertising pressure can turn a lame duck into a tiger.
Cheap contacts become expensive ones
It is understandable that the dynamics of scatter loss are also causing the ranking of contact costs to become rather confused. As part of our mission, contact costs should definitely be assessed on the correct net terms, which tends to be the exception in practice. It is also advisable to ensure the greatest possible cost transparency by adjusting for wastage. It is not uncommon for these corrections to lead to big surprises: Measures that have the image of high contact costs are suddenly inexpensive. Touchpoints such as direct marketing or personal consultations regularly surprise me with good comparative values
in sales.
In addition, innovative data tools can now be used to proactively counteract scatter loss in target group processing, for example when acquiring new customers. The response options, contact quality or even the customer experience are not even evaluated.
Relevance before reach
Everyone knows that reach is by no means everything when it comes to leading customers to a purchase. Our studies show that success lies in the consistent networking of analog and digital touchpoints. For example, our touchpoint analyses regularly reveal that personally addressed invitation cards sent by post, for example, generate additional sales.
generate test drives for new car models and sell more cars as a result.
Regardless of the challenges of optimally covering the customer journey, or precisely because of them, the statement "If you can't measure it, you can't manage it" also plays a central role here.
Checklist
- Measure reach values for the (potential) customers;
- Align advertising pressure with (potential) customers: if in doubt, increase advertising pressure and budgets;
- In addition to the quantitative performance indicator "reach", qualitative criteria can also be used - such as relevance of the interaction, affinity of a target group to a mix of measures, customer experience;
- incorporate targeted action-triggering touchpoints - such as mailings with response options - into the mix of measures;
- realize end-to-end networking of analogue and digital touchpoints across the entire customer journey;
- Measure campaign success to continuously optimize activities.
This guest article first appeared in Werbewoche 11-12/2019.

* Christoph Spengler is founder and managing director of Acceleroman international consulting and research company based in Zurich. For over ten years, Accelerom has been combining management practice and innovative research and supporting clients from analysis to implementation. Everything revolves around the customer's perspective and their customer journey in marketing, sales, communication and services - always holistic, always measurable, always with a focus on impact and profitability.
