WINA brings independent agencies closer together on the international stage

The World Independent Advertising Awards are among the few awards that are exclusively for independent agencies. *Werbewoche* took a closer look.

wina2017

Although the award was only presented for the second time in 2017, it already enjoys great popularity in South America. The reason for this is that WINA was founded by Mauricio Rodríguez. The Colombian and Creative Director of the Watt agency had already founded the Ibero-American creative festival FICE because he was dissatisfied with the existing creative festivals1.

"WINA is still one of the few independent awards and has the chance to become a permanent fixture in the calendar of independent agencies," says Bernhard Herzig, neo-jury member at WINA and CEO of Maxomedia. According to Herzig, this is due to the convergence of disciplines in thematic awards: "Today, no good campaign can do without cross-media or digital marketing. New awards such as the WINA are therefore increasingly geared towards the entrants and no longer primarily towards the type of campaign. The direction WINA takes will also depend entirely on how the entire award landscape develops." Herzig was a jury member in the "Innovation" category this year.

The jury members are also independent

Independent agencies are not necessarily small. For example, the German agency Achtung! (around 140 employees) was at the start. In the USA and South America in particular, there are very large agencies that have remained independent. The largest participant was BRM Grandes Interacciones from Colombia. The company has over 3,200 employees and is independent. "We are all the more pleased that we left some of the really big ones like BRM behind us in the overall ranking. For us as an independent full-service agency, WINA is an exciting competition. We can measure ourselves against agencies in the same position. Nobody has more goodwill than others because of their network. The jury members also come from independent agencies and are therefore not connected," says Herzig.

René Eugster, founder and Creative Director of the agency at the airport, which specializes in responsive dialogue and B2B marketing, finds the fact that the work was judged by a fine, professional jury "very beneficial". Free of obvious vested interests, as is the case even at the biggest competitions in the world. The award ceremony in Barcelona was also characterized by a friendly approach instead of the usual envy." What is special is that the jury presidents come from network agencies. "In this way, they take on a supervisory role and think outside the box," explains Herzig.

More exchange needed

WINA also aims to bring independent agencies closer together on the international stage. "It's time for independent agencies, with their sometimes very independent approaches, to exchange ideas, complement each other and drive great solutions. Nationally and internationally. Project-related co-creation, as we have been doing with Maxomedia for the SBB customer loyalty program for the Swisspass since we won the pitch together." "Most of us are not independent for quality reasons, but rather because of our entrepreneurial attitude."

For Simon Muster, Head of Consulting and Partner at Maxomedia, the international approach is what makes it so appealing: "WINA is the ideal platform for comparing international campaigns without any conflicts of interest arising among the jury members. The stakes are the same for everyone. I am therefore all the more delighted that our work for Swissquote with top footballers from the English Premier League won us silver and bronze plus two further honorable mentions." A total of 90 agencies were shortlisted, and Maxomedia made it to 27th place in the overall ranking thanks to the "Take The Lead in 180°+180°" campaign.2 The agency at the airport was awarded bronze at the first attempt (Werbewoche.ch reported). René Eugster adds: "A single submission in just one category and winning metal the very first time. We are very pleased."

High-level inputs

The quality of the work was high. Top of the overall ranking is the Spanish agency Peanuts&Monkeys, which also caused a sensation at WINA with its 3D-printed Death Star for the premiere of the latest Star Wars film. Element - a Mexican agency that even achieved PR coverage in German-speaking countries at the beginning of the year - was also at the forefront this year.3 For the Corona beer brand, the agency made a political (and commercial) statement for a united America shortly after US President Donald Trump signed the executive order to build the wall. Many projects for well-known brands such as Walt Disney (Peanuts&Monkeys) or Nescafé (Archer Troy) were included.

In addition to Santiago de Chile, the WINA awards were also presented in Barcelona in 2017, as there are many independent agencies in Europe. In contrast to the parallel event in Europe, the event in South America was a festival and took place over two days. (Stefan Kern/hae)

More articles on the topic