Swiss Press: 6th Q-Award presented
Six entries were submitted for the 6th Q-Award, presented by the Swiss Press Association to recognize outstanding trade publications. The jury awarded the 2009 prize to the weekly newspaper «htr hotel revue.» The five other entries all received honorable mentions. In doing so, the jury expressed its appreciation to the industry for the significant improvement in performance, which also extends to the online sector.
Since this thorough relaunch, the newspaper no longer appears as a lobby-driven proclamation organ of the association's leaders, but as a journalistically conceived and realized current weekly newspaper in broadsheet format, which signals a high standard of content, it continues. The diverse and complex linking of the hotel industry and tourism with current social and political dossiers is excellently expressed in the choice of topics and forms of presentation. "The form corresponds to the content and - especially important - to the character of the industry, which is committed to the cultivated enjoyment of life and comfort based on quality. The appearance and layout of the paper are sensual, attractive and image-emphasized. The lengths and the journalistic forms of presentation vary in a pleasant way. Major topics that the industry wants to convey to the outside world are also given the necessary run-out in length."
Commercially, "htr hotel revue" cleverly takes into account the requirements of the market by concentrating its efforts on the processing of the job market and on the quarterly realization of the supplement "Hotelwelten" ("Hotel Worlds"), which focuses on hotel planning, furnishing and operation. The latter does not yet seem to have arrived in the online world, whereas with www.hoteljob.ch a good position in the industry-specific job market was achieved. The jury was very pleased with the carefully edited and beautifully designed online edition of the weekly newspaper, which shows the potential to become a daily industry portal. (www.htr.ch)

Five further nominations at a high level
In contrast to previous editions, this year the jury was satisfied with the level of "cruising altitude" of all the projects submitted. Not a single one really fell off; more than one, on the other hand, seems to have the potential for future awards.
Alimenta - trade journal for the food industry (D/F)
The inherently difficult marginal conditions (bilingualism, bi-weekly publication frequency) are cleverly compensated for. The visual appearance is neat, but somewhat stiff; the Internet presence (www.alimentaonline.ch), on the other hand, is pleasantly tidy and user-friendly.

GS1 network
The periodicity (4 x yearly) prevents topicality, but promotes the deepening. This actually calls for a strong, up-to-date supplement on the web, but this is not yet apparent. The focus on sectors is good, which also makes planning easier for advertisers. Despite the lack of infographics, the use of images is generally good in a topic world that is decidedly text- and form-heavy. (www.gs1.ch)

Family doctor practice
Appears in a distinguished, somewhat academic, aloof impression, but thus undoubtedly adequate for the conservative target audience. The jury particularly liked the consistent thematic focus (continuing medical education, e.g., regarding MCI/dementia/Alzheimer's disease, coronary heart disease, etc.), the understandable language, which nevertheless reveals a clear scientific profile, and the intelligent use of infographic elements. Design and accessibility of the internet offer, especially in the area of continuing education (CME) could be improved. (www.springer-medizin.ch)

OTX World
Despite free distribution and a clearly commercial objective, the independent magazine for the Rx and OTC market in Switzerland stands out for its journalistic and often critical approach to the selection and treatment of topics. Health policy topics are often treated controversially, which is undoubtedly appropriate. Pleasant format, clear layout, good labeling of commercial contributions ("Company XY informs..."); results of the 2009 relaunch not yet visible, networking with online less successful. (www.sanatrend.ch)

Travel Manager
Swiss monthly magazine for the travel industry. Ten years of proven track record and commercial success in the turbulent travel, hotel and airline industry command respect. In keeping with the tradition of the journalistic publishing house, the topics are tackled in a critical and constructive manner, personalized and the differences are openly addressed, which creates credibility and trust. The jury was somewhat disappointed by the quality and variety of the illustrations. In contrast, the online presence is well calibrated. (www.travelmanager.ch)

The jury 2009
The jury for the 2009 Q Awards was unchanged from previous years. It consisted of Pepi Burch, publishing consultant (Zurich), Dr. René Grossenbacher, Managing Director of Publicom AG (Kilchberg), Josefa Haas, Head of the Media Institute of the Swiss Press Association, Karl Lüönd, publicist and book author (Elsau), Urs Schneider, owner of the media agency Mediaschneider (Zurich) and Jürg Siegrist, Managing Director of SWA (Zurich).
