The quality of Swiss annual reports is stagnating
In the 2013 Swiss Annual Report Rating, Swisscom took first place, ahead of Kuoni and Geberit.
Nine medals were once again awarded at this year's rating event on September 19. In the overall ranking, Swisscom took gold ahead of Kuoni (silver) and Geberit (bronze). The Design category was won by Geberit ahead of Kuoni and Valora. In the Value Reporting category, the same places were awarded as last year: Swisscom Gold, Straumann Silver and Credit Suisse Bronze.
The same names have appeared in the top twenty to thirty annual reports for years. It seems that the quality of their reporting is not particularly contagious, as the rest of the 234 annual reports assessed are rated mediocre at best by the juries. Prof. Alexander Wagner from the Institute for Banking and Finance at the University of Zurich, for example, believes that only 59 of the annual reports assessed have sufficient information content. And Peter Vetter, President of the design jury, takes the same line. "The design quality of printed reports has steadily declined over the years. And anyone hoping that this would be compensated for by the quality of the online version will be sorely disappointed."
Exemplary integrated print-online approaches
Good online solutions for business reporting are rare, and harmonious interaction between the two channels of print and online is even rarer. Some of the examples of the top reports stand out from the runners-up. The laudator of the second-placed Kuoni report, Michel Gerber, President of the IR Club, spoke of "an excellent balance between playful animation and user-friendly information transfer in the online version and overall creativity in a relaxed manner that does not overwhelm the reader". It is to be hoped that the Swiss Annual Report Rating will help to ensure that the seeds of creativity and transparency continue to spread. The examples of this are on the table. The top 12 companies in this year's rating share a sure instinct for professional communication.
Andreas Jäggi

The winners at a glance
Design (print and online)
1st place: Geberit
2nd place: Kuoni
3rd place: Valora
Value reporting
1st place: Swisscom
2nd place: Straumann
3rd place: Credit Suisse
Overall ranking of annual reports
1st place: Swisscom
2nd place: Kuoni
3rd place: Geberit
