National Council Wants to Ban Annoying Telemarketing Calls

The National Council wants to ban health insurance companies from making costly calls to customers to promote their health insurance plans. On Wednesday, it narrowly approved a motion from the Left by a vote of 94 to 85, with nine abstentions.

Jacques-André Maire (SP/NE) submitted the motion in 2011, shortly after health insurers had decided to implement self-regulation regarding telemarketing. In Maire’s view, this self-regulation—which provides for numerous exceptions—is not working. The number of calls has not decreased noticeably. Therefore, the federal government must take action by imposing a ban. The Federal Council, however, rejected the motion, arguing that a ban would be virtually impossible to enforce, since telephone marketing often involves brokers who are not subject to any oversight. Furthermore, there is no legal basis for such a ban.

In this context, Health Minister Alain Berset also recalled the protracted discussions of recent years on the topic of telemarketing. A proposal to ban the use of premium funds to finance such calls had already failed in Parliament in 2010. The government has made a new attempt to establish state regulations on the financing of advertising and brokerage services in the proposed Health Insurance Supervision Act. However, this bill is highly controversial in Parliament—and among health insurers. Maire’s motion will now go to the Council of States. (SDA)

Image: Keystone

More articles on the topic