Advertising impact: creativity has a lasting effect

Creatively designed TV commercials are moving. They can make viewers think or laugh. They are popular with advertising agencies and many advertisers as well. But how effective is creative advertising in terms of communication?

A recent study by Grand Valley State University (USA) addressed this question, focusing on the contextual factor "repetition" - with exciting results.

In theory, an ideal commercial would already bring high recall values after the first viewing and would already achieve a significant positive influence on the consumer's attitude at the first contact ("wear in" effect). The ideal commercial would gain in impact with each subsequent contact and never reach the point where a certain fatigue effect sets in with the consumer, which manifests itself in the fact that additional contacts have no further positive or even negative influence on the attitude ("wear out" effect). So much for the theory. In corporate practice, however, far from theory, the goal of those responsible for advertising is usually to minimize the number of contacts needed to achieve the desired advertising effect (= achieving the wear-in quickly) and to delay the wear-out as long as possible. The influence of creativity on wear-in and wear-out effects is shown by a recent study by Lehnert et. al.

In an experimental design, 90 subjects in three groups were shown a 30-minute TV program. Included: TV commercials that were either "creatively" or "conventionally" designed. Only the context factor "repetition" was varied between the three groups: The first group was presented with the different spots only once each, the second group saw the spots twice in total, and the third group four times. The dependent variables measured were: Advertising and brand recall (both aided and unaided, once immediately and once with a one-week time interval) as well as attitude toward the commercial.

Unsurprisingly, the study initially confirmed a well-known correlation: the more frequently the test subjects saw the individual commercial, the better their recall of the commercial and the brand. However, it could also be shown that the creative spots were consistently better remembered than the conventional spots (ad recall). The same applies to the recall of the brands advertised in the commercials (brand recall).

This advantage of creative advertising over conventionally designed advertising in terms of recall apparently comes into play especially when only a few repetitions are planned.

Especially after the first presentation, the "creative" spots achieved significantly higher brand recall than the "conventional" spots. The effect remained with the second repetition, but already weakened somewhat. From the fourth repetition on, both types of spots achieved similarly high values in Brand Recall.

In addition, consumers' attitudes to the spots shown were investigated. The result: even after the first presentation, the creative spots were rated significantly better than the conventional spots (5.52 vs. 4.61 on a 7-point scale). The researchers see this as a sign of a faster wear in creative advertising.

Now, one might assume that the surprise effect of particularly creative advertising wears off quickly and leads to all the more rapid consumer fatigue, a faster wear-out. But the study shows that this is not the case: even after four presentations, the test subjects rated the creative ads only minimally worse than after two presentations. With the conventional spots, on the other hand, consumers' attitudes toward the advertising they had seen deteriorated considerably from the second presentation onward.

Creatively designed spots therefore not only score in terms of advertising recall, but also reach consumers particularly quickly and particularly permanently.

Clemens Koob

wwirkung

Key Facts

  • Creative spots and the brand advertised in them are better remembered than conventional spots. The recall advantage remains even after several repetitions, but weakens.
  • Creative advertising leads to attitude changes more quickly than conventional advertising (= faster "wear-in" effect).
  • With conventionally designed TV commercials, a wearout effect sets in after just a few presentations.
  • In the case of creative TV commercials, this effect only occurs with a delay.

More articles on the topic