Ombudsman criticizes SRF sports report

SRG ombudsman Achille Casanova has upheld complaints against SRF's reporting. The television station had played canned fan chants in the "Sportpanorama" program. This was despite the fact that the fans had remained silent at the start of the match in protest.

For Casanova, the recording of the fan chants is "more than a gross journalistic blunder". The viewers had been misled. This is particularly serious because the fan protest had a political background, writes the ombudsman in his online report, which was reported by various media on Wednesday.

At the football match between GC and FC Zurich on May 12, the fans of both teams demonstrated against the Hooligan Concordat with a joint action. There was no fan chanting during the first 10 minutes of the match. In the "Sportpanorama" program, however, the producers played fan chants from the archive over the silence of the opening phase. Some viewers objected to this and complained to the TV ombudsman. "We are entitled to truthful reporting," the complaint stated.

In retrospect, the SRF sports editorial team apologized and admitted that it had made a mistake. In his statement to the ombudsman, program officer Nök Ledergerber stated that it had never been the intention to depict reality incorrectly. In the "Sportpanorama", the sound of the teams marching in had been corrected "for creative reasons" during editing. In the live broadcast, however, the fan protest was reported "cautiously".

For Casanova, however, the apology is not enough. He welcomes the fact that the case has been used as an opportunity to sensitize the entire sports department to how such issues should be reported. "It would certainly be interesting for SRF's audience to find out what conclusions were drawn from this embarrassing mishap and how such events should be reported in future," the final report states. (SDA)

 

More articles on the topic