Mörgeli rebuffed by SRG ombudsman
The SRG ombudsman has rejected two complaints by the SVP National Council member in connection with the Mörgeli coverage in the "Rundschau" program. He partially approved a third complaint about a follow-up broadcast.
However, Ombudsman Achille Casanova dealt with the numerous complaints in detail and, in some cases, also critically, as can be seen from the three final reports, on which Sunday View and Schweiz am Sonntag reported and which are also available to the news agency SDA.
In an initial broadcast, "Rundschau" accused Mörgeli of waving through numerous "unscientific" doctoral theses and thus not properly fulfilling his function as "doctoral supervisor". On the "hot seat", the SVP politician was then able to justify himself on the accusations for ten minutes, during which the presenter also asked him whether he would now resign as a member of the National Council.
The medical historian felt unfairly treated by the feature and the interview in the "hot seat" and complained about the broadcast to the ombudsman.
One page report
The film report was indeed one-sided, Casanova judged in his final report. Important aspects were left out or not examined in depth. The question about the resignation from the National Council was "a misguided provocation" because it mixed Mörgeli's political and scientific work in a problematic way.
However, because Mörgeli had had sufficient opportunity to refute the accusations in the interview, he could not support the complaint about this broadcast, the ombudsman wrote in his letter to Mörgeli. "Even though I can certainly understand your critical reaction." But the principle of objectivity was not violated in the entire reporting - film report and "hot seat".
Casanova, on the other hand, considers a complaint about the "Rundschau" program of April 3, 2013, which dealt with the topic of what skills are necessary in Switzerland for a doctorate "Dr. med", to be "partially justified". In his final report, ombudsman Achille Casanova states that the audience was "unable to form its own opinion" about this main question. Here the factual fairness requirement was violated. "I therefore consider your complaint, insofar as I was able to address it, to be partially justified."
In total, the Zurich National Council member Christoph Mörgeli objected to three programs - two from "Rundschau" and one from "10vor10".Werbewoche.ch reported).
Mörgeli is not satisfied with these decisions. He wants to take the case to the Independent Complaints Authority for Radio and Television UBI, he told SDA. (SDA)
