"Tamedia must extend innovation beyond the boundaries of the company"

Inspired by the hack days of large companies, Tamedia organized an ideas competition last weekend. Werbewoche spoke to digital boss Christoph Brand about the Open Development Projects and Tamedia's digital business.

position. He addresses the criticism that was leveled at the ideas competition on the web in advance and explains the next steps.

Subscribers to Werbewoche can find a report on the ideas competition in the print edition or as of now online.  

brand

WW: he Open Development Projects were designed for 50 participants. 17 came. Did Tamedia envision the event differently? 

Christoph Brand: From our point of view, the event was a complete success, considering it was the first time it had taken place. We are delighted with the commitment of the young people and the projects that were created.

Originally, the participants were supposed to assign the rights of use. After Criticism from the community, Tamedia adapted the rules and granted the rights to the developers. What will happen to the winning projects now?
In the event of realization, we will hold a commercial discussion with the authors.

What does this mean for the Cubetech agency, which has a Redesign for Search.ch has developed?
Cubetech will present its concept to the management of Search.ch in April. However, this is not a guarantee. It is possible that Search.ch will decide against a redesign. Or that the management will invite other agencies to submit proposals as part of a pitch. The procedure is still open.

This means that Cubetech has not yet won anything.
In addition to the non-cash prizes that the winners received, the competition prize is that the agency will be considered for a possible competition presentation. In my opinion, this is not a bad prize for a small start-up company that would probably not be invited to such a pitch without the Open Development Projects.

What about the ZHAW Group's Fashionfriends project?
There, too, various things need to be clarified first. Among other things, whether the students would even have the time and resources to implement the project. Or whether Tamedia will buy the idea from them. That is still completely open at the moment.

tamedia-03
The fashion board for Fashionfriends design of the ZHAW Group.

Another point of criticism was that Tamedia was buying ideas on the cheap. Why didn't you commission freelancers or agencies to come up with new application ideas?
We award many contracts to agencies and freelancers. The Open Development Projects are about giving people outside the scene a chance. We wanted to reach those who would otherwise not get a chance.

Regarding the digital strategy in general: Tamedia has not yet succeeded in developing successful online projects internally. The bargain platform Scoup.ch was discontinued, Doodle.ch and Search.ch were purchased. Why is that?
That's a good question. Large companies generally find it difficult to successfully launch start-ups from their own ranks.

You mean media companies?
Not only. I know of only a few examples in the telecoms sector. There are certainly a few successful cases. In general, I believe that the DNA of a large company does not tend to be geared towards developing completely new products via start-ups. In the digital business in particular, it is also completely illusory to believe that a company can cover all areas of innovation. In this respect, it is imperative that Tamedia expands innovation beyond the boundaries of the company.

Does Tamedia promote innovation externally, by supporting start-ups or similar?
We do not have a specific funding program for this. If you like, you could see the Open Development Projects as a small-scale funding project. However, this is just one piece of the puzzle. We specifically promote individual start-ups by getting involved at an early stage. This was the case with Fashionfriends and Doodle, for example.

According to Christoph Tonini, the digital sector should already account for 19% of the company's turnover this year (Dreikönigstagung). Where do you expect the greatest growth within the digital sector?
I cannot answer this question. Tamedia does not publish figures for individual business segments...

In other words, which digital projects do you think are promising?
In my opinion, the classified market in Switzerland has not yet been exhausted. We see growth potential there and we will continue to offer new products. The real estate platform Homegate.ch, for example, will launch an online mortgage.

What is the status of the jobs platform Jobs.ch, which Tamedia and Ringier launched last year? Jointly adopted have?  
Tamedia has contributed Jobup.ch, Jobwinner.ch and Alpha.ch, among others, to the deal. The integration is now underway. New offerings will be introduced in the coming months. In French-speaking Switzerland, for example, Jobs.ch was previously the clear number 2 behind Jobup.ch. This means that attractive, comprehensive offers with a wide reach are now possible.

In which digital businesses do you see competition for Tamedia from international groups?
International competition is particularly fierce in the areas related to search and find. A number of providers overlap with Search.ch. Not only Google, but also specific offerings such as Yelp.

If you compare Search.ch with Google: Where does Search.ch score?
Search.ch is not directly comparable with Google. The business models are very different. Search.ch is primarily a directory business and does not offer a search service that competes with Google. The listing business for SMEs is Search.ch's most important line of business.

Google is also using Adwords to attract SMEs...
Of course, Adwords is a way for an SME to be found by customers. However, as with all forms of advertising, the same applies here: The mix is crucial. If all companies only used Adwords, it would ultimately only depend on who invested the most.

Last question: What does the growth in the mobile sector mean for Search.ch?
Many ad-financed sites are struggling with the commercialization of mobile. For Search.ch, on the other hand, mobile is much less of a problem, as we earn most of our money not from display advertising but from listings. These are paid for - regardless of whether an entry is ultimately accessed by the end user via mobile or desktop. Search.ch is therefore much more relaxed about the mobile trend than purely ad-financed sites.

Interview: Isabel Imper

To the print article about the Open Development Projects: Inspiration from outside.

 

More articles on the topic