Touchdown Social Media
Beat Hürlimann is a freelance advertising professional and a passionate observer of the national and international social media scene. He shares his insights exclusively in *Werbewoche* and on his blog, Huerlimanncc.com.
Wide receiver Anquan Boldin of the Baltimore Ravens completes the 13-yard pass of his quarterback Joe Flacco with a touchdown. 108.4 million Americans watch several hours of a show interspersed with a total of 47 minutes of advertising with a book value of $376 million. Welcome to the advertising year 2013, welcome to a short replica of Super Bowl Night on February 3, the biggest American sporting event with an integrated advertising festival - or vice versa. On the field, the two NFL finalists duel for the Super Bowl, and on the screens, TV commercial productions battle for viewer favor. The Ravens have defeated the 49ers. But who landed the most touchdowns during the commercial breaks with the public? We take a look at the performance of the Super Bowl commercials shown and look for patterns of success. The result is three rankings and three insights.
#Ranking 1 - Top of Social Media Shares: Here are the ten spots with the best distribution figures in the two social media channels Facebook and Twitter. According to the Super Bowl spot analysis, beer, cars and movies are particularly suitable sources of stories to tell.

#Ranking 2 - Top of Video Views: The ten spots with the most views on video portals can be seen here. There is obviously a correlation between the distribution of spots via social media channels and their number of views on video portals (six matches). Two exceptions prove the rule: Toyota is the clear video leader with 15 million views, but only ranks 33rd in the social media rankings with 19,000 shares. Samsung also struggles with the conversion rate from views to shares (0.45%). The more than 13 million viewers are offset by a comparatively low 58,000 retransmissions (rank 18). The best conversion rates among the top ten are achieved by the Budweiser and Fast&Furios6 spots with 20% each. Remarkably, car brands account for 60% of all video views from the ten most-watched Super Bowl spots.

#Ranking 3 - Top of Video Likes: Here are the ten spots with the most YouTube likes. Unsurprisingly, yet revealingly, they are the same spots in the top five positions as in the social media ranking. This is further confirmation of the finding that positive news spreads significantly better than negative news.

The poster boy among Super Bowl commercials is Budweiser's Brother Hood drama "Clydesdales." It's about the relationship between a horse breeder and a brewery horse that develops into friendship as they grow up. Years later, during a horse show, the two friends have a heartfelt reunion. Great spot cinema with lots of emotions and goosebump music. The beer drama received the most YouTube likes (55,000), social media shares (over 2 million) and mentions on Twitter (15,000).

An exception is provided by the domain provider Godaddy. com. Its spot "The Perfect Match of Nice and Smart," in which top model Bar Rafaeli (Nice) and her chubby-cheeked antipode Walter (Smart) get closer while kissing, is ranked 10th in the social rankings (151,000 shares), but with over 11,000 dislikes (with 9,000 likes and 10.5 million views) it is one of the very few Super Bowl spots to have a negative balance.

The provocateur among the Super Bowl commercials gave rise to cheerful tweets and found great echo in the media:

#Ecognition 1: Storytelling
Three things connect the two spots from Godaddy. com and Budweiser. Both have made it to the top ranks of the most watched and most shared commercials. They are both knitted according to the same storytelling pattern: As the plots unfold, surprising and emotional events bring about twists and turns that provide the material for further storytelling. Drama or comedy? According to Hollywood screenwriter and author of the bestseller "Save the Cat" Blake Snyder, every cinematic work can be assigned to one of these two types of dramaturgy. Budweiser, epic drama with a happy ending. Godaddy.com, sparkling sexy comedy to look at or away from. And both create clear references to the brand (Budweiser with brewery horse) and the service (Godaddy.com with the matching approach) respectively.
Detergent manufacturer Tide delivers another Super Bowl commercial story with a whimsical stain protection comedy, "Miracle Stain." It is also a prime example of contextual storytelling. The spot makes direct reference to the event. Joe Montana is an '80s San Francisco 49ers legend, and it's about his likeness as a miraculous stain as a result of a ketchup squirt on a Super fan's shirt. There's no way to put this commercial down. You have to have seen it. With 1.1 million views and 107,000 shares, it just misses the top ten.

#Ecognition 2: Call to Action
According to a snap poll, 36% of viewers used second screens (smartphones, tablets, PCs, laptops) during the broadcast to obtain information and share their experiences of the Super Bowl spectacle. Gar 52% said they used social media channels during the game, sharing info about the game and explicitly about the commercials. 75% of the Super Bowl spots also offered viewers Facebook links, Twitter hashtags or mobile apps for mutual interaction.
These "second screen experiences" open up creative design fields for us advertisers to place effective calls to action. We have already analyzed three of them - shares, views and likes. Now it's time to analyze targeted action triggers with subsequent lead generation. The most effective calls to action prove to be those that, firstly, come out of the actual spot story and, secondly, call for participation. Budweiser, for example, asks viewers in its blockbuster spot to suggest names for two freshly born Clydesdales foals. Just two days later, the brewery is able to present its two foals, freshly christened Hope and Stan, via this tweet. The news soon spread by the thousands.

The cookie brand Oreo has come up with a particularly product-oriented form of co-design. The cornerstone is a funny spot comedy. In a library, the question of what tastes better on an Oreo cookie, "Cream or Cookie?", sparks a heated argument that degenerates into tumultuous scenes. The cream-or-cookie debate quickly spreads across Twitter. With the hashtags #Cremethis or #Cookiethis, users are asked to send in photos of items.

In a hall, these are recreated in real time by patissiers with the desired ingredient as a confectionery sculpture and uploaded to Instagram, where they are shared tens of thousands of times with friends, tagged thousands of times with likes and showered hundreds of times with positive comments.

#Ecognition 3: Real-time advertising
The Super Bowl show highlight was a blackout. The lights went out for 30 minutes in the Mercedes-Benz Super Dome. Audi proved to be a particularly nimble player in the advertising field and promptly scored a wonderful Twitter touchdown with the audience. 9,000 retweets and 3,000 favorites after just a few minutes - Vorsprung durch Technik.

The Super Bowl blackout offered viewers a half-hour advertising spectacle, and for us advertisers it provided a few illuminating insights into how to deal with social media channels. 1) Current references are gratefully received and passed on by the audience. 2) Provided they are funny. 2. provided they are funny, surprising and have a comprehensible connection to one's own brand. 3. live coverage of an event is required, distributed via a medium with as large an audience as possible. 4. the presence of a powerful team of story writers, designers, digital cracks and decision makers is essential.

The almost perfect benchmark package for real time advertising is provided by the cookie brand Oreo Cookie with this social media ad: 1. Oreo Cookie is already represented in the Super Bowl advertising block with its own, extremely funny TV spot. This increases the attention. 2. in just a few minutes, the Oreo team creates a rich media ad with a suitable image idea. 3. the ad meets the requirements of the usual social media channels and can therefore be distributed simultaneously via them with a single mouse click. 4. the story creates a coherent tension between event, event and product. Twitter users thanked us with a record-breaking 15,950 retweets! These links will take you to more facts and figures about the effectiveness of this year's Super Bowl commercials: www.viralvideochart.unrulymedia.com, www.pinterest.com/huerlimann/ super-bowl-ads/. It's worth a detour! I'm interested in your thoughts, opinions and preferences around the Super Bowl commercial show. Spark exciting conversation with a post at www.huerlimanncc. com.
Beat Hürlimann
