Short reports on major events remain free
The public has the right to see TV footage of major events—even if a television station has paid a lot of money to acquire exclusive rights. The EU's highest court has now reaffirmed the right to brief news coverage.
Short TV reports on important football matches and other major events will continue to be available to all TV broadcasters. This was decided by the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in Luxembourg on Tuesday. The background to this is a legal dispute between the TV broadcaster Sky Austria, which had spent several million euros on exclusive rights to the Europa League between 2009 and 2012, and the public broadcaster ORF. The pay-TV broadcaster failed with a lawsuit against the obligation to provide other broadcasters with images practically free of charge.
Sky Austria had argued in court that the EU rules on short reporting violated the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union. The rights to property and entrepreneurial freedom are guaranteed there. However, the highest EU judges ruled that Sky Austria's property rights to the exclusive football images were not violated. It is true that the EU directive, which also stipulates the right to short reporting, restricts the freedom to conduct a business. However, this was justified and proportionate.
The Court found that "the exclusive commercialization of events of great public interest is currently on the increase and is likely to significantly restrict the public's access to information about those events". Short reporting pursues "an objective in the public interest, since its purpose is to safeguard the fundamental right to freedom of information and to promote pluralism".
The situation is similar in Switzerland, where legislation also provides for the right to short reports on public events. Even if a television station has the broadcasting rights for an event, other stations can report on it. However, the duration of the reports is limited. The provisions apply in particular to sporting events.(SDA)
