Publishers are selling their content at ever higher prices
In their search for a new business model, Swiss publishers are seeking more and more money from readers: This is why they are increasing subscription rates again in 2013 and often also the prices at the newsstand. More and more publishers are also turning to online payment methods.
Newspaper publishers are running away from advertising customers and subscribers, first of all to the Internet. A lot of newspaper content is free there and advertising prices are low. However, the mobile use of their content is far worse from the publishers' point of view - because advertising revenues are even lower in the mobile sector. As a result, publishers are losing subscription revenue and even more so advertising revenue. This is why publishers are looking for a new business model. "We don't have it yet," admitted the outgoing Tamedia CEO Martin Kall in an interview with NZZ am Sonntag at the beginning of December.
At the same time, he said what direction the industry is currently looking in: "Advertising revenues are not enough, so we are now trying the paywall on the Internet." Two surveys conducted by Werbewoche confirm Kall's statement: the survey on advertising rates published in the last issue of Werbewoche shows that only a quarter of newspapers are venturing an open increase in advertising rates for 2013. Several have even stuck to the same page price for ten years. However, the second survey now available shows that more than half of the newspapers are planning a paywall or another form of paid content - or have already introduced one. Many prefer the "classic" variant: Whether via PC or cell phone - the title's own articles are only freely accessible to print or online subscribers. In individual cases, a small selection of own articles is activated. The current survey also shows that two thirds of all newspapers are increasing their subscription rates as of 2013 - and not for the first time: some do so annually. In other words, publishers are going easy on advertising customers and are increasingly taking the money from readers.
The "old aunt" is downright cheeky
Of the 60 titles and 17 subscription combinations surveyed here, only 26 kept their subscription price at the previous level. All the others are adding between 0.8% (Le Nouvelliste) and 15.1% (Finanz und Wirtschaft, FuW). In absolute figures, there are surcharges of up to 50 francs - as in the case of the aforementioned FuW, which now costs 382 francs. Those who want to combine the St. Galler Tagblatt with the new Ostschweiz am Sonntag will also pay CHF 50 more than before from March 1. The NZZ follows in second place, exceeding the CHF 600 mark with a surcharge of CHF 33 and now costing CHF 628 per year. Its subscription price development is remarkable: in 2009 the NZZ subscription still cost 488 francs, since then it has been raised by over 30 francs annually - since then the price has risen in four steps by a total of 140 francs or 29%. This makes the NZZ the title that most radically explores its users' willingness to pay. The "Old Aunt" is approaching the highest subscription price in this country to date, that of the western Swiss business newspaper Agefi, with huge leaps: its annual subscription costs 700 francs - although it has remained constant for years. Incidentally, the Tages-Anzeiger also charges more every year: since 2009, its subscription has increased by 21% or 77 francs from 364 francs at the time.
Two other titles that are asking their readers to pay significantly more in this round are the Südostschweiz Glarus and Gaster See editions: their subscriptions are increasing by 29 and 30 francs to 322 and 339 francs, while Südostschweiz Graubünden is leaving its rate unchanged at 353 francs. This shows that In Chur, they are working towards a uniform subscription rate for all editions. Incidentally, the biggest price increases in French-speaking Switzerland are to be found in Tamedia titles: 24 Heures, Tribune de Genève and Le Matin semaine will cost a uniform CHF 429 from 2013, CHF 20 more than before. The situation is also special in north-western Switzerland: Basellandschaftliche Zeitung and bz Basel are taking a confident stance and for the first time are charging ten francs more for their subscriptions than their competitor Basler Zeitung.
Newspapers also cost more at the newsstand
Users are also being increasingly challenged financially when it comes to single copy sales. Although the Wochenzeitung remains the most expensive newspaper at CHF 6 per newsstand copy, the FuW, which now costs CHF 5.50, is already hot on its heels. It is followed at some distance by the Basler TagesWoche (CHF 5). The Rheintalische Volkszeitung is making the biggest price increase: it is raising its EV rate by one franc or 50% to 3 francs. Others, such as the Nouvelliste and the Zürcher Oberländer, will now cost CHF 2.50, 25% and 50 centimes more than before respectively. The Walliser Bote and Sissacher Volksstimme are also charging an additional 30 centimes. Most other titles, including the Tamedia titles in French-speaking Switzerland, are adding 20 centimes at the kiosk, with a few adding 10 centimes. Incidentally, with its 20% surcharge, Volksstimme now costs 1.80 and is no longer the newspaper with the cheapest EV rate. La Quotidiana, which has kept its newsstand price at CHF 1.60, now holds the record for the lowest price, followed by Boten der Urschweiz, which continues to cost CHF 1.70. There is something special to report from French-speaking Switzerland: Le Temps and La Liberté are reducing the price of their Saturday editions by 11% and 5% respectively. A Saturday edition of Le Temps now costs CHF 4.20 instead of CHF 4.70 at newsstands, while La Liberté now charges CHF 3.70 instead of CHF 3.90 on the same day.
Three pricing strategies for e-paper and app
In the online sector and especially in the e-paper segment, three strategies are emerging among publishers. Agefi, for example, sees itself as primarily responsible for providing the respective content on various channels - on paper, as an e-paper, on the website or via an app for mobile use. Users can choose what they want, but they always pay the same subscription price. The second approach is more common with smaller newspapers: Online access to content - especially via app - represents an additional expense for them, which they also charge extra for. Volksstimme, for example, charges its print subscribers an additional CHF 50 if they also want to use the new app. Similarly, Bote der Urschweiz and La Gruyère charge print subscribers an additional CHF 20 and CHF 30 respectively for using the e-paper.
The third philosophy is that digital subscriptions and often apps are cheaper than print subscriptions because there are no printing and distribution costs. However, there is no consensus in the industry as to how much these costs amount to. Most reductions compared to print subscriptions are between 20 and 35 percent, but Blick, SonntagsBlick, Zürichsee Zeitung, Le Nouvelliste, Tribune de Genève and La Liberté also grant discounts of up to 50%. Others are stingier: for example, the e-paper of the Rheintalische Volkszeitung is just 1% cheaper than the print subscription, while the Freiburger Nachrichten is 11.5% cheaper, the St. Galler Tagblatt 13.4% and the Bund 17.8%.
The "ideal" tariff for the digital subscription is still pending
It is also interesting to note that some e-paper titles are still looking for the ideal subscription price. This is indicated by some steep price changes. For example, 24 Heures, Tribune de Genève, Le Matin semaine, La Liberté, Le Nouvelliste and La Regione Ticino have reduced their e-paper subscriptions by between 46% and 49% as of 2013, while Quotidien Jurassien and Südostschweiz am Sonntag have reduced theirs by 33%.
Conversely, there are apparently also titles that previously offered their EPaper subscriptions at too low a price - they are increasing their prices significantly. These include Freiburger Nachrichten (+41.1%), La Gruyère (+30%) and St. Galler Tagblatt (+22.8%). The three-tier subscription model of Le Temps is also striking: The print subscription costs CHF 504, the e-paper subscription CHF 384 and the app subscription previously cost CHF 360. However, the latter was reduced by 66.7% to 120 francs in 2013, which is why it is now 76% cheaper than the print subscription. Does the calculation still add up? The Neue Fricktaler Zeitung's approach is also special: its print and e-paper subscriptions each cost 184 francs, while the app subscription costs 240 francs, i.e. 31% more.
Markus Knöpfli
