Picking at the Great Wall of China
Editorial departments should be more accommodating of advertisers’ wishes and be more open to their concerns even in the editorial section. However, what a prominent advertiser of print ads and TV spots demands from the media is also a subject of controversy within the advertising industry.
What Gerhard Schürmann, CEO of the car dealer Emil Frey, said at the Publishers' Congress was explosive: He would like to see more interfaces between editorial contributions and topics offered by advertisers. Why not an interview with a star who talks about cars? The demarcation between editorial and advertising business, defined as the "Chinese wall," would have to be torn down. Dominique von Matt (Jung von Matt/ Limmat), on the other hand, said at the same panel discussion that more important for good advertising is a credible environment that cannot be bought. What do other advertising experts think?
Markus Ruf, Creative Director at Ruf Lanz, shares Matts' opinion: "When I look at our press landscape, I get the feeling that there are already some titles that are happy to accommodate Mr. Schürmann's wishes. However, we believe that a clear separation between editorial and advertising business is important, because advertising needs a credible environment. Clients should acquire the attention of the audience - not buy it. They can do this by communicating in a more surprising, entertaining and smart way than others. That's what we do for our clients every day."
Peter Marti, owner of Marti.Seiler AG, sees it quite differently: "Marti. Seiler always negotiates editorial support with publishers during media planning. In practice, the weightier the medium, the less this takes place. Greater flexibility would be desirable here. After all, editorial coverage of products need not have a negative impact on editorial quality. In the aforementioned example of an interview with a star about a certain car brand, the only thing that matters is that it meets high journalistic standards. Of course, this also puts the onus on the clients and their agencies. It is up to them to provide the publishers with good ideas and editorially perfectly prepared articles. Or to support them in the production of relevant articles. A well-written driving report is certainly more exciting than a boringly written essay about an unattractive spring exhibition without ideas or stars. Definitely, I believe that the 'Chinese Wall' behind which many editors and journalists hide must be torn down in the spirit of a journalistic spring. And I am not writing here about the 'product pages' on which all publishers, from the NZZ to the Automobil Revue, already place perfumes and travel paraphernalia editorially. I am writing about larger editorial contributions. Dear Dominique, we both grew up in a theological home. I took my first advertising steps with your brother Jean-Rémy. And now, at the media congress, you are talking about a credible, non-buyable editorial environment, which is supposed to be the prerequisite for good advertising. The times of high credibility of the media are over since the financial and political crisis, since Facebook, Twitter and YouTube. Both the editorial teams (e.g., Murdoch wiretapping scandal) and the advertising agencies (e.g., last Renault campaign in Switzerland) have sinned. Credible information is being replaced by fun and entertainment. You can see that, dear Dominique, in the media figures. The question remains whether we both like this development with our clerical background. Well, in the Vatican is also tricked and lied ... and this since 2000 years."
René Eugster, owner of Agentur am Flughafen, says: "Basically, nobody buys a newspaper because of the great ads. Just like people don't use the feature film between the commercial breaks to take a piss. Dominique von Matt is absolutely right. Of course, a credible environment for good advertising is more important than ever. But where does that still exist? Maybe in grassroots social media channels, where companies invite dialogue and then get shocked when stakeholders actually take it up? Perhaps there are even negative statements about the brand that the advertising CEO might not like, whereupon he immediately gives the agency the order to censor or declares Facebook to be unsuitable for his company once and for all. Journalism has come under extreme pressure today. Our customers know this, too. Haller wrote in his textbook (a standard work in Swiss master's courses) back in 2005 that around 50 percent of reporting at dpa is based on PR material. In 88 percent of the cases, he said, the core message of the PR template is adopted. So what is this hypocrisy in 2012? Against this background, good advice from an advertiser acting with calculation is certainly not easy. However, we tend to advise our clients to stage good and relevant stories that pay into the brand account. Of course, we also try to penetrate the editorial space - provided that the relevance and the willingness to provide open information exist. In the B2B market or in trade or special interest magazines, this has always been an open secret, because ultimately the ad and the editorial piece want to motivate the same target group to take the same action with the same information. Simply through different approaches. As long as the reporting is honest, accurate and relevant, I still trust a good editor to exercise sound judgment on behalf of their customers/readers. Then the moment has come when we also advise our client to use a media-appropriate individualized, well-staged story in the editorial environment."
Geri Aebi, CEO of the Wirz Group, has a different opinion: "This is truly an explosive topic that Schürmann is bringing up. I'm sure he speaks from the heart of some of his clients! I myself spent almost 15 years in Austria - a country where the strict separation between editorial and advertising has long since been more or less abolished in many print media. Yes, this non-separation or mixing even forms an essential motive for founding and financing new magazines and newspapers in the first place. From correspondingly painful experience as a reader, but also as an advertiser, I have to say: Tried both, no comparison - please let's preserve and protect editorial independence as long as we can! The compromise solution of the inflation of public reports, which is rampant not least in certain specialist media, is still the lesser evil... Seen in this light, I absolutely agree with Dominique von Matt. Whereby I gladly admit: Depending on the title - and this certainly applies more to special interest magazines than to daily newspapers (and there especially to their "theme" supplements!) - a certain editorial affinity to the products advertised in ads is no longer surprising in this country. At the same time, people leaf through them accordingly and perhaps expect a bit of well-designed entertainment, but certainly not objective information from the relevant articles."
Finally the statement of Curdin Janett, CEO Publicis Communications Switzerland: "We fight for consumers' attention. And this is highest where they are interested and involved. In other words, in a high-quality environment. That's why I still consider the separation of editorial and commercial activities to be right and important. If we place our messages in the highest-quality environments, we achieve the best results. Nevertheless, nothing stands in the way of a well-implemented media cooperation with a client - if it is well thought out and well done, it can also be clearly identified as such. If there is added value for consumers, everyone is served." He answered the question of whether the media should be more open in their editorial reporting to products for which advertising is also paid for in the negative, but he does see differences in expectations compared to daily newspapers, magazines and special interest magazines: "In the case of daily newspapers, readers expect independent and interest-free reporting. We should respect this. In the case of consumer magazines with a lifestyle focus, cooperation can be interesting and entertaining for clients and readers - and thus also generate additional benefits for the publisher. Whereby I am still in favor of clear labeling. After all, with a well-crafted story, there's nothing to hide. In the case of special interest magazines, the reader is also aware that the proximity of providers and media in the specific market is higher. But here, too, it's true that anyone who disseminates PR without criticism has no credibility and is therefore of no long-term interest to either the readership or advertisers." Today, publishers and editors-in-chief are confronted with increased demands from the advertising industry and their clients. The "code of conduct" they launched is being put to the test.
Pierre C. Meier
(The article first appeared in an abridged version in the media magazine Edito).
