Sodastream: Advertising censorship in England
The British Advertising Standards Authority has banned a TV commercial by Sodastream. It interprets the advertisement for the sparkling water maker as a «denigration» of the beverage industry.
Sodastream, the market leader in drinking water bubblers, has launched its first global TV campaign. The claim: "If you love the bubbles, set them free" is intended to draw attention to the waste and lack of sustainability on the part of major drinks manufacturers. When the Sodastream machine is activated in the commercial, thousands of conventional pet bottles burst. At the end, the viewer is told that they can save 2000 bottles a year with Sodastream.
The campaign was created and implemented by the Common agency, the commercial was broadcast extensively in the USA and has already been viewed over a million times on YouTube. In contrast, the Sodastream campaign was less well received in England. Clearcast, an organization that checks TV advertising before it is broadcast and is closely networked with the largest TV stations, decided to ban the ad. The reasoning: People would understand the advertisement more as a request not to buy drinks in supermarkets and less as an opportunity to protect the environment through Sodastream. The commercial denigrates the bottled drinks market.
Daniel Birnbaum, CEO of Sodastream, describes the reasoning as absurd. It has probably not often happened that the media has mobilized against an environmental protection idea in order to protect a traditional industry. Of course, the beverage bottle industry is being challenged, but offering a pioneering alternative has nothing to do with denigration. After all, an iPod advertisement does not denigrate the Walkman, nor does a car advertisement denigrate the horse and cart. Of the 629 billion drinks bottles produced worldwide, one billion are thrown away every day - the Sodastream ad shows people that there are smarter ways to enjoy soft drinks.
