Effie Awards Switzerland: Who's Turning the Impact Screw?
At Sihlcity, Cedric Schild had the advertising industry in stitches. Some would have liked to hear more about the case studies. Later, Switzerland Tourism took home the prize in the Papiersaal with an idea that had been in the works for five years. A good moment to ask what impact is still worth anything when AI makes one thing cheaper above all else: more advertising.
An Emotional Roller Coaster
A name is called. The team stands up. Applause, an Effie, back to their seats. Until Cedric Schild calls out the next case. This is how the Effie Award Night at Zurich’s Sihlcity finds its own rhythm. The m&k video captures this ebb and flow, from the first round of applause in the theater to the confetti in the Papiersaal.
«Every winter, Switzerland faces a question of faith.» That’s how McDonald’s case film begins. Raclette or fondue? At the Arena Cinema Sihlcity, the film barely gets past the question the second time around. «We’ve already seen this,» can be heard in the auditorium. True. McDonald’s and TBWA have already won gold once this evening for the showdown between McRaclette and McFondue. Now here’s the second one. Applause. Next.

For an awards show, that’s a good punchline. For an Effie, it would also be a good moment to ask: What exactly did the same case prove twice? In one category, it’s about how to turn a product launch into a debate that draws in radio, the press, and the public. In the other, it’s about what happens at the counter. According to the submission, over 1.3 million of the two burgers were sold, and McDonald’s saw a 3.5 percent increase in customers. The same story, two different reasons for gold.



Big Screen, Short Cases
For the first time, Leading Swiss Agencies is hosting the Effie Award Show at the Arena Cinema Sihlcity. Swiss social media journalist, comedian, and host of the evening, Cedric Schild, calculates the audience’s odds of winning, spots the award-winning teams in the audience, and keeps the evening moving. Grand Juror Valerio Stallone noted on LinkedIn that Schild struck the right tone. The industry was able to laugh at itself, and the award-winning work took center stage. In conversations that evening, however, some had a different take. They would have liked to learn more about the challenge behind each entry, how the idea came about, and what criteria the jury used to assess its impact. For them, the event at the cinema was too much of a show and not enough of a case study.

The question concerns the format. Schild’s pacing works in the cinema. That’s precisely why it’s striking how quickly the segment flies by—the very thing that sets the Effie apart from other awards. The Swiss jury evaluates the initial situation and objectives, insights and strategy, the execution of the idea, and the results. The latter, accounting for 30 percent, carries the greatest individual weight. This is the triad that could have sparked a lively debate after the show. Creativity opens up a new path. Effectiveness shows whether it leads to the destination. Efficiency asks how much the journey cost. Anyone who sees mainly the two-minute result on the screen only gets a glimpse of this interplay.
One town sign, two juries
Migros provides the best real-world example of the relationship between the ADC and the Effie. Its “Town Sign” campaign by thjnk Zurich won the ADC Grand Prix in June and an Effie Gold award in the Retail category in November. The ADC focuses on creative excellence. The concept can be explained using a single image. A real town sign bearing the name Joke, along with chickpeas. For the Effie, there’s a second question: Did this play on place names make Migros’s regional roots more understandable and credible? According to the submission, the campaign reached about two-thirds of the Swiss population. People and brands created their own concepts, and some of their suggestions made it into the next wave of the campaign.
Both awards compete for the attention of the same industry. When it comes to the town signs, their judgments complement each other. The ADC honors the creative idea. With the Effie, the same idea must demonstrate what it has achieved for the brand. Alexander Jaggy of thjnk wrote on LinkedIn after the event about just how much work goes into this second aspect alone. His agency won 14 awards, and he expressly thanked the people who researched, validated, and wrote the entries. «Ironically, the path to an award for effectiveness has absolutely nothing to do with efficiency.»

The party you miss?
The party atmosphere was also a topic of conversation that evening. Some recalled earlier advertising parties that, according to their stories, were wilder. They were referring to the industry as a whole. Looking back this way, one also mourns a time when the advertising world celebrated itself more uninhibitedly. It remains unclear how much of this is due to the evening itself and how much to nostalgia. In any case, Stallone recounts on LinkedIn how he celebrated with the winning team in the Papiersaal. His attempt to round up the entire Grand Jury for a group photo failed. The winning photo, however, turned out well.
The evening continued on LinkedIn. Agencies highlighted their awards, thanked clients, and put the spotlight on teams whose work had only briefly been featured during the awards ceremony. Webrepublic, for example, explained why real apprentices showcased their daily lives on TikTok and Snapchat as part of the silver-winning campaign for login Berufsbildung. The campaign was designed to attract young people to technical and skilled-trade apprenticeships. According to Case, digital applications and hires in hard-to-fill professions saw double-digit growth. This suddenly made room in the feed for the question that some had missed in the theater: Why did this particular project win an Effie?

The Presidents’ Voices
In March, Lara Jelinski and Daniel Fischer had in the m&k Vlog explains what makes a piece of work worthy of an Effie in her view. Eight months later, the two of them are on stage in the Papiersaal as the first co-chairs of the Effie jury. Before them lies the final award of the evening. No name is announced yet. First, they describe how intensely the Grand Jury debated the Gold-winning entries and what ultimately tipped the scales.
«Less is more,» Fischer had said in March. He was referring to the focus of a case. What problem needed to be solved? What idea brought about a change? And how can that change be identified? For Fischer, a number needs a point of comparison—such as with the previous year, with the industry, or with a control group. In the same conversation, Jelinski asked about the investment. How much impact did a team achieve with the resources it had at its disposal?
In the cinema, this approach had already taken on quite a variety of forms. In the ’cheese duel” campaign by McDonald’s and TBWA, the impact could be tracked all the way to the counter. The case study shows over 1.3 million burgers sold and a 3.5 percent increase in customers. In the case of the Halbtax PLUS by SBB and Contexta, the focus was on whether customers would understand a new public transportation offer and actually purchase it. The submission reports more than 204,000 sales in the first year. The numbers tell a different story in each case because the objectives were different.
In the Papiersaal, another question arises. What can an idea accomplish over the course of several years? In its rationale, the Co-Presidency highlights the guiding principle that remained recognizable over five years and could be adapted to ever-changing tasks. Then the category «Sustained Success». «And does it work?» Switzerland Tourism and the Wirz Group win the Grand Effie for «When Switzerland Is the Star.».

The co-stars appearing alongside Roger Federer changed, as did the reasons for the trips. Sometimes it was the Grand Tour, sometimes train trips, sometimes fall travel, and sometimes longer stays. The campaign resulted in over 430 million YouTube views and a 50 percent reduction in cost per effective video view. Another piece of data is added to assess the impact. The submission shows increased demand for promoted offers such as the Swiss Travel Pass and the Grand Train Tour. This brings together the two perspectives from the March discussion in the winning case study. The platform reached its audience with decreasing costs per view while also demonstrating that interest in specific offers was growing.
The two had also discussed AI in March. Fischer saw opportunities for faster measurement, personalization, and more flexible ad delivery. He had already outlined the prerequisite back then: A team must know what impact it wants to achieve before optimizing its delivery strategy accordingly. In light of this Grand Effie win, the question can now be posed even more specifically: What would a brand lose if, in its next round, it focused solely on improving whatever can be measured the fastest?
Is AI Taking Things Too Far?
The easiest way to get started with AI is to begin with the Production Iterate. A team can get drafts, language versions, and variations for different channels more quickly. This can save money and create room for better experiments. The focus is intensified where the feedback is considered most important. If a design gets more clicks, it receives a larger budget. The next round delivers even more of the same. It remains to be seen whether anyone books a trip because of the campaign, applies for an apprenticeship, or even remembers months later which brand came up with the idea.
And then there’s creativity. Anyone who uses the same tools to optimize for similar signals can come close to what already works well. This makes the individual variant useful and can make the work in the market more similar to one another. In an experiment with short stories, readers rated AI-assisted texts higher on average. At the same time, these stories were more similar to one another. This raises an obvious question for advertising: How much brand recognition will a brand retain if all its ads are enhanced in the same way?

Two Silver Case studies illustrate just how varied a compelling response can be. For Toblerone Celebrity Hype Students sent personalized 4.5-kilo bars to celebrities who were on tour in Switzerland. According to Case, the total cost of 575 francs—excluding the media budget—resulted in a reach of eight million and a 1.3 percentage point increase in Swiss household penetration.

At 31DAYS SBB and 42hacks had selected car drivers try out public transportation for a month. According to Case, the participants subsequently spent 25 percent more on public transportation than a structurally comparable control group. One study highlights what an original idea can achieve with a small budget. The other demonstrates how carefully one can evaluate a change in behavior.

That’s where the Effie’s value lies. The ADC can celebrate the moment when an industry encounters an extraordinary idea. The Effie can show it what happened after that encounter. The faster campaigns emerge and the easier it is to measure their initial impact, the more interesting the question of proof becomes. In the judging room, the jury selected an idea whose story has been told and retold over the past five years. In the movie theater, that would have been a good reason to stay seated for just a moment longer during the next case.
m&k-Service | The Award-Winning Cases from the 2026 Effie Awards Switzerland
🏆 Grand Effie
When Switzerland Takes Center Stage
Switzerland Tourism × Wirz Group · Sustained Success
For five years, the co-stars alongside Roger Federer and the reasons for his travels kept changing. Switzerland remained in the leading role. This earned the country first a box-office hit and later the Grand Effie award.
🥇 Gold
- McRaclette vs. McFondue — McDonald’s Switzerland × TBWA Switzerland
Two Gold Awards · Brand Content, Entertainment & Experiential Marketing · (Professional) Services / Restaurants - The Migros Place Name Sign Campaign — Migros Supermarket × thjnk Zurich
Retail - When Switzerland Takes Center Stage — Switzerland Tourism × Wirz Group
Sustained Success · Also Awarded the Grand Effie
🥈 Silver
- The Great McDonald’s Rebrand — McDonald’s Switzerland × TBWA Switzerland
(Professional) Services / Restaurants · Brand Image - Grittibänz in a Mercedes — Migros Supermarket × ESE Agency
Brand Content · Retail - Less Time on Your Cell Phone Leads to Greater Brand Loyalty — Sunrise × thjnk Zurich
Brand Content · Consumer Goods & Telecommunications - From Underdog to High-Growth Brand — Allianz Suisse × Wirz Group
Brand Image - An Effie Case Without All the Fuss — Chocolat Frey / Migros Supermarket × thjnk Zurich
Brand Image · Food & Beverages - Without me, Switzerland comes to a standstill — login Vocational Training × Webrepublic
Institutional & Recruitment, Government - The best job prospects in the world — SBB × Farner / Team Farner
Institutional & Recruitment, Government - When you're in a wheelchair, you're never alone — Swiss Paraplegic Foundation × Best regards
Nonprofit - Child Protection Switzerland — Child Protection Switzerland × Neu Creative Agency
Nonprofit · Positive Change* - Migros Playmobil Mania — Migros Supermarket × Wirz Group
Retail - Authenticity as a Brand Value — CSS × Sir Mary
Sustained Success - Zweifel x Aromat – The Chip Flavor Switzerland Wanted — Zweifel × Jung von Matt Limmat
Timely Opportunity - Toblerone Celebrity Hype — Mondelēz International × Bagels of Berkeley
Small Budgets - From Product Feature to Brand Value — Sunrise × thjnk Zurich
Consumer Goods & Telecommunications* - Bank Cler. The advertising, well... but the interest rate is good. — Bank Cler × Neu Creative Agency
Finance* - 31DAYS – Attracting Car Drivers to Public Transportation — SBB × 42hacks
Transportation, Travel & Tourism
🥉 Bronze
- 100 Years of Migros – MERCI — Migros Supermarket × Wirz Group
Brand Content · Corporate Reputation - Brand over price wars – Winning Black Week with a soft touch — Brack.Alltron × brinkertlück creatives
Commerce & Shopper Marketing - Safety Quest — SAFE AT WORK × Ogilvy
Digital Marketing - Be Ready with Emmi Caffè Latte — Emmi × TBWA Switzerland
Food & Beverages - Doubts at KEZZ – We do everything we can to make the crispiest chips — Zweifel × Jung von Matt Limmat
Food & Beverages - Launch of the SBB Half-Fare PLUS — SBB × Contexta
Product/Service Launch - The Coupon Coup — McDonald’s Switzerland × TBWA Switzerland
Timely Opportunity - Fly with SWISS, Stay a Switzerland Fan — SWISS × thjnk Zurich
Timely Opportunity - For Fans of Switzerland — Switzerland Tourism × Wirz Group
Transportation, Travel & Tourism - Bank Cler. The advertising, well... but the interest rate is good. — Bank Cler × Neu Creative Agency
Finance* - Child Protection Switzerland — Child Protection Switzerland × Neu Creative Agency
Positive Change* - SWISS Schöggeli XXL — SWISS × thjnk Zurich
Transportation, Travel & Tourism - From Product Feature to Brand Value — Sunrise × thjnk Zurich
Consumer Goods & Telecommunications* - The Migros Place Name Sign Campaign — Migros Supermarket × thjnk Zurich
Retail*
The Grand Jury
Yvonne Baumgartner, Regula Bührer Fecker, Johanna Gollnhofer, Andreas Hugi, Roman Reichelt, Oliver Schönfeld, Philipp Skrabal, and Valerio Stallone. Lara Jelinski and Daniel Fischer served as co-chairs of the Effie judging panel.






