Radio Top must pay Suisa fees in arrears

Radio Top failed to pay copyright fees to the Suisa cooperative for the music it played over a period of several years. The Federal Supreme Court has ruled that the station must now make up for these unpaid fees. However, the exact amount remains to be determined. The Commercial Court of the Canton of Zurich will decide on the matter.

Radio Top

Radio Top and Suisa have been at loggerheads for years over copyright fees. Because the station and the cooperative could not agree on the correct calculation, Suisa finally made short work of the matter three years ago.

It terminated Radio Top's license as of April 2018. Since then, Radio Top is actually no longer allowed to play any music from the Suisa repertoire. However, Radio Top refuses to comply with this broadcasting ban, claiming that it is arbitrary.

Radio Top has a right to Suisa's repertoire, the station argues. The federal concession stipulates that part of the broadcasting time must be filled with music. If Radio Top did not do this, the station would have its license revoked. Suisa is thus abusing its monopoly position.

Suisa demanded 1.8 million Swiss francs

Suisa, for its part, demanded a total of 1.8 million francs from the radio station in eastern Switzerland. However, the cooperative only arrived at this amount with the help of an estimate based on figures from the Federal Office of Communications.

According to Suisa, Radio Top had not disclosed its income relevant to the tariff "despite repeated requests and reminders". Suisa had also tried to explain to the broadcaster the obligation to pay the fees, but in vain.

At least for the years 2014 to 2016, the broadcaster had therefore violated its legal and collective bargaining obligations to provide information. As a "punitive action," Suisa also doubled the fee owed.

Federal court does not want "punitive action"

The Federal Court has now ruled that Radio Top cannot avoid paying fees. The performance mandate does not release the station from respecting copyrights and thus from paying Suisa the fees for playing the music.

However, the Federal Court does not think much of the "punitive action" by Suisa, i.e. the doubling of the fee, as can be seen from the ruling published on Wednesday.

There was no evidence that Radio Top had intentionally or grossly negligently provided incomplete or false accounts, the Federal Court wrote. Radio Top had justified the missing information among other things with personnel changes and reorganizations.

How much Radio Top must now pay in arrears has not yet been clarified. The Federal Court is sending the case back to the Zurich Commercial Court for a precise determination of the amount of the fee. (SDA)

More articles on the topic