Schweizerische Lauterkeitskommission SLK Archives - m&k https://www.markt-kom.com/en/tag/schweizerische-lauterkeitskommission-slk/ The creative side of the economy Tue, 30 Jun 2026 07:52:35 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 https://www.markt-kom.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/favicon-150x150.png Schweizerische Lauterkeitskommission SLK Archives - m&k https://www.markt-kom.com/en/tag/schweizerische-lauterkeitskommission-slk/ 32 32 Schweizerische Lauterkeitskommission: Rekordjahr 2025 https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/schweizerische-lauterkeitskommission-rekordjahr-2025/ Mon, Jun 29, 2026 07:55:01 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/de/?p=258085
Philipp Kutter, President of the Fair Trading Commission.

Fair advertising requires clear evidence

With 240 complaints, the Swiss Fair Trading Commission (SLK) once again set a record last year. The 2025 Annual Report shows that the most common reason for complaints was misleading or inaccurate information in commercial communications—45.4 percent of all cases fell into this category, including complaints related to greenwashing. Aggressive sales methods came in second at 14.9 percent, followed by sexism in third place at 8.8 percent.

President Philipp Kutter sums up this year’s key message in a single sentence: Fair advertising must be clear, accurate, and verifiable. This is precisely how the SLK evaluates commercial communications—in the interest of consumers as well as in the interest of a credible advertising industry.

New Member: Dr. iur. David Aschmann.

Selected Decisions of the Swiss Fair Trading Commission

The activity report illustrates the SLK's work through specific cases. These cases demonstrate the range of topics addressed—from hotel advertising to environmental claims to fitness claims on social media.

A natural hotel cove instead of a fine sandy beach

In an advertisement for a hotel, the beach location was described, among other things, using the terms «sand,» «natural,» «swimming platform,» «swim shoes recommended,» and «private.» The complainant considered this to be misleading: in reality, the bay was mostly rocky, with slippery and sharp-edged stones; swimming was virtually impossible without a pontoon. The SLK dismissed the complaint. In its view, the descriptions «unspoiled,» «swim shoes recommended,» and «swimming platform» in particular made it sufficiently clear that this was not a fine sandy beach with easy access to the sea. The average consumer would expect natural obstacles based on such a description.

SLK criticizes Tabs for making unsubstantiated CO2 promises. Source: zvg

Produced without CO2? Environmental claims must be verifiable

The packaging of dishwasher tablets stated that the tablets were manufactured entirely in France, at a factory that operated without CO2 emissions. It also claimed that the production site recycled all waste. The SLK partially upheld the complaint: The claim regarding manufacturing in France could be substantiated. However, it was not sufficiently proven that the entire factory operates without CO2 emissions and that all waste is recycled. The Commission notes that environmental claims must be clear, true, and verifiable based on objective evidence.

Advertised as organic cotton, but delivered as polyester

An online store advertised a sweater as a product made from organic cotton. However, after placing her order, the complainant received a sweater made of 100 percent polyester, manufactured in China. The SLK upheld the complaint. The seller had not submitted a statement; the complainant’s claims therefore remained uncontested. The decisive factor for the Commission was that the advertisement created an impression that did not correspond to the product actually delivered. Information regarding material, origin, and product characteristics must be truthful and clear.

Sweater: Advertised as organic cotton, but delivered as polyester. Source: zvg

1,200 calories in a short period of time

An Instagram promotional video advertised a treatment or device with a bold claim of effectiveness: it promised to burn up to 1,200 calories in a short period of time. The SLK upheld the complaint. It deemed the statement to be a specific performance claim that the public would understand as a measurable promise of effectiveness. The provider was unable to substantiate the accuracy of the statement. Particularly in the fitness and beauty sectors, the rule applies: Anyone who advertises specific effects must also be able to prove them.

60 Years of SLK and a New Member of the Foundation Board

On the occasion of the 60th anniversary of the Swiss Fair Trading Commission, President Philipp Kutter spoke in an interview with persoenlich.com about landmark decisions, political calls for stricter advertising restrictions, and the continued effectiveness of voluntary self-regulation. According to Kutter, the Federal Council has repeatedly stated that the Fair Trading Commission’s work is of great value.

In addition, the Board of Trustees of the Foundation for Fairness in Commercial Communication welcomes a new member: Dr. iur. David Aschmann. A doctor of law and linguist, he serves as a judge on the Federal Administrative Court and, according to his own statements, has proven expertise in intellectual property and competition law.

For more information on the 2025 Annual Report and the chambers' decisions, please visit https://www.faire-werbung.ch available.

]]>
Lauterkeitskommission verzeichnet Rekordzahl an Beschwerden https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/lauterkeitskommission-verzeichnet-rekordzahl-an-beschwerden/ Mon, 31 Mar 2025 12:18:00 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=232725

The SLK is the self-regulatory body of the communications industry and monitors compliance with the rules for fair commercial communication.

With 221 complaints procedures in 2024, the SLK has reached a new high. A record of 124 proceedings had already been recorded in 2023, but the 200 mark has now been exceeded for the first time. A major factor in this increase was a controversial billboard advertisement by a brothel operator, against which around 100 complaints were received - 70 of them in a single day. The accusation was sexism. The complaints will be dealt with in the first half of 2025.

If this wave of submissions is deducted, the number of complaints procedures remains at the 2023 level. In the long term, the average is around 100 cases per year. The leisure, tourism, hotel and catering sector accounted for the most complaints in 2024 (12.3 %), followed by food and beverages and services and administration (10.9 % each). There was an increase in the areas of trade, industry and services, while mail order, food and home & garden declined.

In the media sector, a third of complaints (33.3 %) related to online advertising, followed by direct marketing (22.6 %) and out-of-home advertising (12.5 %). Social media and product labels were also the subject of proceedings. In terms of content, most complaints concerned misleading advertising, which accounted for 39.6 % of all cases. This also included complaints about greenwashing, i.e. questionable environmental promises. Sexism was the subject of 12.3 % of cases, while aggressive sales methods (21.6%) were on the decline.

More than half of the appeals submitted (52.8 %) were upheld, 34.7 % were rejected and the Boards were unable to hear 12.5 % of the cases. All appeals were rejected. The SLK emphasizes that appeals are often filed with the aim of forcing a reconsideration, which is not the purpose of the procedure.

In addition, public and media interest in the work of the SLK is increasing. In 2024, over 50 media inquiries were received from all parts of the country. Questions about influencer marketing and the transparent labeling of commercial partnerships were particularly frequent. The use of artificial intelligence in advertising and greenwashing were also recurring topics. The SRF format "10 to 10", for example, was dedicated to the question of how AI is used and declared in advertising.

Individual exemplary decisions of the SLK are in the activity report to read.

 

]]>
2023 war ein Rekordjahr für die Schweizerische Lauterkeitskommission https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/2023-war-ein-rekordjahr-fuer-die-schweizerische-lauterkeitskommission/ Tue, 09 Apr 2024 11:56:54 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=213342

At the annual meeting of the Foundation for Fairness in Commercial Communications, the Board of Trustees approved the 2023 activity report of the Swiss Fairness Commission SLK. In 2023, a total of 124 complaints procedures were conducted - 40 percent more than in the previous year.

In the last three years, the number of complaints procedures has remained at a high level. The long-term average number of complaints procedures is around 90 per year. The SLK has approved just over half, around 54%, of the complaints. This represents a slight increase compared to previous years.

Most complaints in the food/beverage sector

Most complaints revolved around classic consumer topics. At 14%, the food/beverages sector recorded the highest proportion of complaints, followed by the home/garden (10.5%) and leisure/tourism/hotel/restaurant (9.9%) sectors. There was an increase in complaints compared to the previous year in the pharmaceutical/health and alcohol/tobacco sectors.

In terms of media, the internet/email remains by far the frontrunner (37.6%), followed by direct marketing (23.8%) and out-of-home advertising (9.5%). Social media, which has only been measured separately since 2021 and accounts for around 8.5% of all complaints this year, has seen a steady increase in the number of complaints.

International interest in complaint about climate neutrality of a sports tournament

The fact that the Fairness Commission has upheld a complaint against a sports association's communication about the climate neutrality of a sports tournament has caused an international stir. Media around the world reported on this decision. It has now become legally binding.

The public also responded with interest to the new directive on the "Commercial communication with an environmental focus / with environmental arguments"which the SLK has drawn up. It clarifies which requirements must be met if a company advertises with environmental arguments, i.e. engages in green marketing.

Once again, the activity report lists individual, exemplary decisions. It should be noted that the complaints procedure before the Fairness Commission is a simple, summary procedure in which there is no extensive taking of evidence as in the state courts.

]]>
SLK schafft Richtlinie gegen Greenwashing https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/slk-schafft-richtlinie-gegen-greenwashing/ Wed, 20 Dec 2023 10:00:05 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=208227
Image: Eddie Iglesias; Unsplash.

The Swiss Commission for Fair Trading (SLK) has published a new Guideline on advertising with an environmental or climate focus. The guideline clarifies which requirements must be met if a company advertises with environmental arguments, i.e. engages in green marketing. Advertisers are given information on what they should take into account and what is relevant for the SLK in any complaints procedure.

For the first time, this directive provides concrete guidelines for Switzerland on what should be taken into account in commercial communication with an environmental reference or with environmental arguments so that the requirements of fair trading law are met. "The directive is a guide to positive, fair action, not a prohibition directive," explains Reto Inglin, Legal Secretary of the Fair Trading Commission.

Complaints about greenwashing on the rise

Although the SLK has been dealing with complaints in the area of green marketing for many years, there has recently been a noticeable increase in such complaints. Individual cases are attracting a lot of attention, such as the SLK's decision published last June in connection with FIFA's communication on the climate neutrality of the 2022 FIFA World Cup in Qatar. The new directive summarizes the previous SLK case law in this area and integrates international developments, in particular the EU directive on environmental claims. This is not a matter of adopting EU law, but rather of selectively incorporating international considerations regarding the promotion of transparency, clarity and truthfulness in communication.

An internal working group of the Commission on Fair Trading examined whether an amendment to the SLK's principles was necessary. It came to the conclusion that the existing legal basis is sufficient to examine the fairness of commercial communications with an environmental connection.

The new directive does not create any new rules, but rather specifies the requirements for when green marketing fulfills the truth and clarity requirements in fair marketing law. "Our aim is to create clear guidelines. We are convinced that this will be of great benefit to all players in commercial communication," says Reto Inglin.

]]>
Werbung mit Klimaneutralität ist gemäss Kommission unlauter https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/werbung-mit-klimaneutralitaet-ist-gemaess-kommission-unlauter/ Tue, Oct 31, 2023 4:10:23 PM +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=205704
(Iconic image: Unsplash.com)

Slogans such as "CO2-neutral", "climate-neutral" or "climate-positive" are therefore misleading despite the label, Consumer Protection announced on Tuesday. If companies do not adjust their advertising, the State Secretariat for Economic Affairs Seco must take action against them, the foundation concludes based on a verdict of the Fairness Commission SLK.

In two decisions on the cases of a heating oil company and a baby food producer, the SLK states that advertising with climate neutrality is unfair. As long as there are no definitive, generally accepted methods for measuring sustainability or ensuring implementation, such so-called green marketing messages would mislead consumers.

According to the recommendation of the SLK, the heating oil company should no longer claim that its heating oil is climate-neutral before it submits complete proof. This would have to include a calculation of the production-side climate impact and complete proof of its compensation - using a generally accepted method.

The manufacturer of infant formula advertised with the slogan "our jars are climate positive." The company claimed that its environmental protection projects overcompensate for its own CO2 emissions. In the absence of concrete information and evidence, the SLK recommends that this company also refrain from using the statement.

At the same time as the complaints to the SLK, Consumer Protection had also filed complaints against unfair climate advertising with Seco. These are still pending.

The foundation describes the lack of legal requirements for environment-related advertising as a fundamental problem. As long as the requirements are unclear, advertising with "green" statements must be considered unfair. The advertising messages would have no verifiable truth content. (SDA)

]]>
SLK: Kein Nachweis einer klimaneutralen WM https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/slk-kein-nachweis-einer-klimaneutralen-wm/ Wed, 07 Jun 2023 09:33:05 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=198612

With its statements, some of which were absolute, the world football association Fifa had created the "false and misleading impression" in its commercial communication that the World Cup in Qatar was already climate-neutral or CO2-neutral before and during the tournament, the SLK announced on Wednesday. The burden of proof lies with the advertising company.

In the proceedings, however, Fifa had not been able to prove the accuracy of these statements. It did state that it had already compensated for the 3.63 million tons of CO2 protected in advance. But it had not been able to prove this compensation and had not submitted a concept for any further compensation.

Even if the estimate should correspond to the final figures, it remained unclear to the SLK whether the promised compensation was at all realistic. It is also unclear whether the compensation measures comply with Swiss standards. These required, among other things, "a complete and permanent removal of CO2 from the atmosphere".

Recommendation for waiver of statements

The Second Chamber of the SLK therefore upheld all five appeals from Switzerland, France, Belgium, the UK and the Netherlands. "As long as there are no definitive and generally accepted methods to measure sustainability or to ensure its implementation," a company is not allowed to claim that sustainability goals have been achieved.

The SLK recommends that Fifa refrain from calling the World Cup in Qatar climate neutral in the future - unless it is able to prove all CO2 emissions of the tournament and their offsets at the time of communication.

Climate Alliance delighted

One of the complainants, Climate Alliance Switzerland, reacted with satisfaction to the decision. Among other things, it had criticized the fact that Fifa had not taken into account the effects of the shuttle flights from Dubai, Riyadh or Kuwait to Qatar in its calculations. CO2 emissions from the construction of the stadiums had also been ignored.

The ruling is therefore "a strong message to all companies that want to engage in greenwashing," it said in a statement. Companies and organizations such as Fifa can no longer avoid dealing with their actual footprint.

The Swiss Fairness Commission is a self-regulatory body of the communications industry. It issues recommendations, but no judgments that can be enforced by the state. The decision is not legally binding. (SDA)

]]>
Lauterkeitskommission weist Rekurse zu Influencer-Entscheiden ab https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/lauterkeitskommission-weist-rekurse-zu-influencer-entscheiden-ab/ Thu, 28 May 2020 00:45:48 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=121912 Rekurse zu Influencer-Entscheiden ab

The consumer protection had also filed "several new complaints", the SLK announced on Thursday. The two rejected appeals against tennis player Roger Federer and influencer Xenia Tchoumi, as well as the complaint against mountain biker Yolanda Neff, were about the obligation to label advertising in social media posts.

According to the report, Federer posted a professional promotional video showing, among other things, the logo of his current sponsoring partner. It was clear from the presentation that the tennis star was advertising for the brand owner, writes SLK.

In the case of Tchoumi's post, it also seemed clear that it was commercial communication, even though the jewelry presented was not labeled accordingly, according to the report. The fact that the influencer stated that she had no collaboration with the advertised brands was not relevant, as it is often part of the influencers' strategy to advertise brands only with a view to doing business with them in the future.

In Neff's case, the Fairness Commission did not make a decision because the mountain biker had accepted the complaint from the beginning.

 

Reference to current case law

However, judging a new case, as in the case of the influencer complaints, also shows that it takes a certain number of cases for a "consistent ruling practice to become established. In its decisions, the Fairness Commission also takes into account current case law abroad "in the sense of the multinational character of social media accounts.

Like the SLK principles, this does not include a general labeling obligation. The decisive factor is whether the commercial nature of a communication is clearly recognizable or not.

According to SLK, new scientific studies indicate that young followers are able to identify the commercial persuasive intentions of a post even without labeling due to the specific content design and definitely have a critical attitude towards influencer posts.

In Switzerland, any person has the authority and legitimacy to complain to the SLK about commercial communications that they believe are unfair.

On May 6, at the plenary session, three experts were approved and two newly elected to the Fairness Commission, according to the statement.

 

New experts for the Fairness Commission

On May 6, 2020, three experts were bid farewell and two newly elected. Stefan Szabo from the Institute of Intellectual Property (IPI) replaces Emmanuel Meyer, who has supported the SLK as an IPI expert for eight years, as a specialist in the field of intellectual property law and Swissness. Also new is Roman Gertsch, COO & Co-Founder of the agency Kingfluencers.

On an interim basis, Andreas Häuptli, Managing Director of the Swiss Media Association, is putting himself at the service of fair advertising. Until a definitive replacement is found, he replaces Mirjam Teitler, who has served as expert for print media since 2016. Also stepping down is Lorenzo Cicco as expert for TV advertising; he will be replaced at a later date. (SDA/pd/hae)

]]>
Beschwerden gegen Influencer haben in der Schweiz zugenommen https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/beschwerden-gegen-influencer-haben-in-der-schweiz-zugenommen/ Thu, 02 Apr 2020 22:11:57 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=120537 SKS

The SLK had dismissed two complaints in October 2019: Roger Federer and Xenia Tchoumitcheva did not make any surreptitious advertising according to the commission.

 

This is due to numerous complaints filed by the Foundation for Consumer Protection (SKS) against prominent Swiss influencers, as the Swiss Fairness Commission (SLK) announced on Thursday.

The SKS had objected to a film by Roger Federer and a post by Xenia Tchoumitcheva on Instagram with the Fairness Commission because they were not marked as advertising. However, the SLK had rejected their submissions (Werbewoche.ch reported). The SKS filed an appeal against these decisions. This is to be dealt with in May, Thomas Meier of the SLK told Keystone-SDA.

The SKS also objected to contributions from snowboarder Iouri Podladtchikov and mountain biker Jolanda Nef. Here, the consumer protection foundation was proven right.

Almost 20 percent of all complaints concerned this area. Slightly more complaints were filed about possible violations of the principles against gender discrimination (22.5). In third place were complaints about aggressive sales and advertising methods (12.4 percent).

Because the number of complaints against influencers has increased sharply, the Internet is now the most affected media channel, accounting for 37.5 percent of cases. The number of complaints against print campaigns has fallen from around 17 to just over 7 percent in the last three years, according to the statement.

 

Half of the complaints approved

Of the total of 97 cases, the SLK approved half. Slightly more than a third were rejected, and the SLK did not take action on the remainder. In most cases, the SLK relied on the Unfair Competition Act (UCA).

Eight percent of all complaints were competition complaints filed by a company against competitors. Just under 12 percent concerned laws and directives such as the Trademark or Coat of Arms Protection Act, the Price Disclosure Ordinance (PBV) or the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) Code on Marketing Communications.

In Switzerland, any person is authorized and legitimized to complain to the Swiss Fairness Commission about commercial communications that they believe are unfair. (SDA)

]]>
SLK überarbeitet Grundsätze wegen Influencer-Marketing https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/slk-uberarbeitet-grundsatze-wegen-influencer-marketing/ Sun, 17 Nov 2019 16:27:00 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=117059 influencer-marketing

In July, on the other hand, the Fairness Commission had approved two complaints from consumer protection in the first ever rulings on influencer advertising in Switzerland. Snowboarder Iouri Podladtchikov and mountain biker Jolanda Neff had engaged in unfair surreptitious advertising on the Instagram platform.

Snowboarder Podladtchikov had his picture taken in the entrance of a clothing store. Cyclist Neff distributed a post from a credit card company.

The relatively young genre of advertising influencers poses challenges for the Fairness Commission. What is illegal surreptitious advertising, what is correctly declared, what is paid advertising, what are private posts without an advertising background?

How the SonntagsZeitung writes in its current issue, SLK is now taking action and adapting the formulated principles in at least one case next week. Until now, these were mostly designed for classic editorial content - print and television. Accordingly, the SLK demands a clear separation of information and advertising. Specifically, there is talk of "separation between editorial information and commercial communication".

Such principles are not very handy for bringing cases to the Social media to be judged. There, influencers do not create any actual editorial content. The formulated separation is too narrow, says SLK spokesman Thomas Meier, to the SonntagsZeitung. The term "editorial information" should give way to a more comprehensive formulation such as "content" or "conent".

"We don't care in which medium a content or commercial communication is posted. We simply want to protect consumers from being misled," says Meier.

The main aim here is to protect a younger audience. Social media are among the most important sources of information for young people; YouTube and Instagram stars are role models and have a correspondingly great power. This is where the SLK wants to pick up. It also wants to create awareness for the responsibility of influencers, says Meier.  

 

]]>
Fall Federer wegen eines Rekurses erneut vor Lauterkeitskommission https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/fall-federer-wegen-eines-rekurses-erneut-vor-lauterkeitskommission/ Wed, 13 Nov 2019 12:01:45 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=116961 tchoumi-federer

The SKS had objected to a film by Federer and a post by Tchoumitcheva on Instagram with the Fairness Commission because they were not marked as advertising. However, the Lauterkeitskommission rejected their submissions. (Werbewoche.ch reported). The SKS filed an appeal against these decisions.

The appeals will therefore be dealt with by the plenum of the Fair Trading Commission - the three boards of appeal combined - in the spring of 2020, the Commission announced on Wednesday.

In its first rulings on influencer advertising last July, however, the Fairness Commission upheld two complaints from the Consumer Protection Association and reprimanded snowboarder Iouri Podladtchikov and mountain biker Jolanda Neff. They had engaged in surreptitious advertising on the Instagram platform in an unfair manner.

The reasons given for the various rulings on influencers were contradictory, SKS managing director Sara Stalder explained the appeals to the Keystone-SDA news agency.

The SKS has also filed complaints with the Fairness Commission in six other influencer cases. It wants to work towards ensuring that the commission can develop a reliable decision-making practice and, in the best case, guidelines for influencers, as Stalder says.

In its deliberations, the Fairness Commission found that the title of the principle "Separation between editorial information and commercial communication" is too narrow and misleading, as it writes. It wants to adapt it so that it is clear that newspapers, radio, television and all media that produce content are meant. (SDA)

]]>
Federer und Tchoumi machten laut SLK keine Schleichwerbung https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/federer-und-tchoumi-machten-laut-slk-keine-schleichwerbung/ Fri, 18 Oct 2019 19:59:26 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=116140

As the Foundation for Consumer Protection (SKS) announced on Friday, the Commission for Fair Trading has rejected its two complaints in this regard. The SKS had objected to a film by Roger Federer and a post by Xenia Tchoumi on Instagram because they were not labeled as advertising.

According to the SKS press release, the Commission on Fair Trading does not deny that both cases involve commercial communication. However, it is clearly recognizable for the "average addressee" that this is advertising.

Tchoumi's entire account, on which she prominently presents brand jewelry, is purely commercial in nature. Individual posts would therefore not have to be labeled as advertising. With athletes such as Federer, it is common and easily recognizable that brand logos are presented for purely commercial reasons.

 

First rulings on influencer advertising

In July, on the other hand, the Commission on Fair Trading approved two complaints from consumer protection in the first ever rulings on influencer advertising in Switzerland. Snowboarder Iouri Podladtchikov and mountain biker Jolanda Neff had engaged in unfair surreptitious advertising on the Instagram platform.

Snowboarder Podladtchikov had his picture taken in the entrance of a clothing store. Cyclist Neff distributed a post from a credit card company.

A person who receives sponsorship services or comparable payments or benefits in kind must disclose their relationship to the person providing the service, the Commission on Fair Trading stated at the time, justifying the inadmissibility of the advertising and the approval of the SKS complaints.

 

SKS: "Confusing decisions"

For SKS Managing Director Sara Stalder, these are "confusing decisions", as she is quoted in the press release. The rules are not only unclear for influencers and consumers, but also contradictory. The different assessments are incomprehensible.

"There is now chaos as to when advertising on social media must be labeled," commented Stalder. On behalf of the SKS, she called for the Fairness Commission to "establish comprehensible rules" for advertising on social media portals.

The SKS intends to submit further complaints against influencers in order to clarify the unsatisfactory situation. It will decide whether to appeal against the decisions that have already been made after reviewing and comparing the detailed justifications. (SDA)

tchoumi-federer
]]>
SLK behandelt erste Beschwerden zum Thema Influencer-Marketing https://www.markt-kom.com/en/markom/slk-behandelt-erste-beschwerden-zum-thema-influencer-marketing/ Tue, 10 Sep 2019 14:13:15 +0000 https://www.markt-kom.com/?p=114790 oster-eier

Not sexist due to the factual connection to the advertised service, but still does not belong in the public space: The SLK approves the complaint against the advertisement of a sauna club operator (Photo: Screenshot Tele Bärn).

 

The Third Chamber of the SLK had to adjudicate on an impressive 19 appeals at its meeting on June 19, 2019. In addition to the three cases on the subject of influencer marketing, which had already made waves in advance, the three elected chamber members and the 13 advising experts had other interesting questions to answer. For example, whether the stop-advertising sticker also applies if the advertising is sent as an insert in an order from a mail-order company.

Of the 19 appeals it dealt with, the Third Board upheld six, dismissed eight and decided one appeal in part. In addition, one appeal was not taken into consideration and three were not substantively examined because the respondents had submitted. This means that they had already given credible assurances before the Board meeting that they would no longer use the advertising in question.

 

Influencer marketing under increased media scrutiny

Of a total of five complaints filed by a consumer organization against well-known Swiss celebrities for allegedly violating the obligation to separate content and advertising in their Instagram accounts, the Third Chamber was able to judge three in its June session. Of these, it approved one, rejected one and, in the third case, accepted that the sportswoman concerned had submitted.

  • Approved: The complaint that was upheld concerned an athlete who advertised the clothing line of a sports equipment supplier on his account, including the statement "what to wear". Since this outfitter is also one of the athlete's main sponsors, his justification that he had made the post purely out of personal interest and that it was not a commercial communication did not seem comprehensible in any way.
  • Rejected: This case involved a post by a TV presenter and musician in which she thanked the crew with whom she had filmed her new music video for their collaboration. At the end of the list of 15 corresponding hashtags, she linked a bar, a shopping mall and a fashion label, which was interpreted by the complainant as advertising. The SLK disagreed, as the three hashtags in question were not specifically singled out and did not make any promotional statements; moreover, when producing such a video, it is customary to thank those involved.  
  • Subjected: In the third case, the athlete submitted to the complaint before it was dealt with by the SLK. This means that she credibly assured that she would comply with the separation requirement in the future and would mark her posts accordingly. For this reason, the Third Board did not substantively assess the appeal and did not comment on the athlete's suggestions as to how she would label advertising in the future. 

 

Seximus: The factual context is central

The appeal against the advertising of a sauna club was upheld by the SLK, although the required factual connection between the advertised service and the type of advertising was given. The Third Board did not find any fault with the presentation. However, the claim "Easter? Lick eggs! When shaved...". Such detailed descriptions of erotic services are not appropriate in the public sphere. In contrast, the same complaint was rejected which was directed against the media agency responsible for placing the advertisement on this billboard. According to Art. 8 Par. 2 of the SLK's Rules of Procedure, a complaint must always be directed against the advertising company.

The complaint against a paid post on the website of a newspaper was also rejected. The services of an erotic dating agency were advertised. Within the framework of the constitutionally guaranteed economic freedom under Article 27 of the Federal Constitution, it is not unlawful to offer and advertise erotic services as long as they do not violate Principle No. B.8 "Sex-discriminatory commercial communication". In the view of the Third Chamber, the post in question did not do so, all the more so as there was a factual connection between the form and the advertised offer.

 

Other cases in the overview

  • The limits of the stop advertising sticker: The complaint of a private person was directed against an online mail-order company that had sent unaddressed advertising along with the ordered goods. In this case, the stop-advertising sticker is not effective. According to Art. 27 of the Federal Constitution and Art. 19 of the Code of Obligations, a company is free to decide how to structure its offer. The appeal was dismissed.
  • Test reports must be independent: An online platform for financial services published a test report on five providers of money exchange services. The complainant, a direct competitor, complained that the platform did not make it clear that the author was one of its own employees. SLK's guidelines set high standards for tests and require, among other things, that the tester be neutral. This means that there must be no cooperation between the tester and the tested. The complaint was upheld.
  • Complete business details only in business transactions: In one complaint, it was objected, among other things, that the respondent had not published its address in full in a publicity report, as required by the Commercial Register. In doing so, the complainant did not take into account that, according to Principle No. B.10, a company must only adopt the entry in the Commercial Register unchanged in business dealings. A public report is not a business transaction within the meaning of Art. 954a para. 1 of the Code of Obligations. The appeal was dismissed.
]]>